Rivas Homero, Martínez José-Luis, Delgado Salva, Vidal Jusep, Lacy Antonio M
Obesity Surgery Unit, Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Institute of Digestive Diseases, Hospital Clinic, University of Barcelona, Corporació Sanitària Clínic, Villaroel 170, 08036 Barcelona, Spain.
Obes Surg. 2004 Oct;14(9):1247-51. doi: 10.1381/0960892042386878.
The current attitudes among European bariatric surgeons toward the laparoscopic bariatric operations were examined.
150 questionnaires were sent to recognized bariatric surgeons in Europe, and 60% responded.
47% of respondents perform laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGBP), 81% laparoscopic adjustable gastric banding (LAGB), and 29% laparoscopic biliopancreatic diversion with or without duodenal switch (L-BPD/BPDDS). For BMI <40, 57% of respondents would only perform LAGB, 7% LRYGBP, 2% vertical banded gastroplasty (VBG), 3% L-BPD/BPDDS, and 2% intra-gastric balloon. For BMI 40-50, 43% of respondents prefer LAGB, 11% LRYGBP, 8% VBG, 5% L-BPD/BPDDS, and 33% contemplate several operations. For BMI 50-60, 30% prefer LAGB, 23% LRYGBP, 5% VBG, 16% L-BPD/BPDDS, and 26% tailor each patient's treatment. For BMI >60, 20% prefer LAGB, 24% LRYGBP, 37% L-BPD/BPDDS, 2% VBG, and 17% consider more than one operation. Although important, BMI and patient eating habits are not significant in choosing an operation for 25% of respondents. Interestingly, 39% of the surgeons offer laparoscopic bariatric surgery to so-called pediatric patients (<18). Of these, 76% favor LAGB, 8% LRYGBP, 8% L-BPD and 4% other procedures.
The overall body of respondents prefers laparoscopic procedures. The responses suggest that at lower BMI there is a higher trend for restrictive operations. However, as BMI increases, combined and malabsorptive operations are preferred. At least one-third of surgeons offer bariatric surgery to patients with age <18 years, and here LAGB is greatly preferred.
对欧洲肥胖症外科医生对腹腔镜肥胖症手术的当前态度进行了调查。
向欧洲知名肥胖症外科医生发送了150份问卷,60%的医生进行了回复。
47%的受访者开展腹腔镜Roux-en-Y胃旁路术(LRYGBP),81%开展腹腔镜可调节胃束带术(LAGB),29%开展带或不带十二指肠转位的腹腔镜胆胰转流术(L-BPD/BPDDS)。对于体重指数(BMI)<40的患者,57%的受访者仅会实施LAGB,7%会实施LRYGBP,2%会实施垂直束带胃成形术(VBG),3%会实施L-BPD/BPDDS,2%会实施胃内球囊置入术。对于BMI为40 - 50的患者,43%的受访者倾向于LAGB,11%倾向于LRYGBP,8%倾向于VBG,5%倾向于L-BPD/BPDDS,33%会考虑多种手术。对于BMI为50 - 60的患者,30%倾向于LAGB,23%倾向于LRYGBP,5%倾向于VBG,16%倾向于L-BPD/BPDDS,26%会根据每位患者的情况制定治疗方案。对于BMI>60的患者,20%倾向于LAGB,24%倾向于LRYGBP,37%倾向于L-BPD/BPDDS,2%倾向于VBG,17%会考虑不止一种手术。尽管BMI和患者饮食习惯很重要,但对于25%的受访者来说,它们在选择手术时并不具有决定性意义。有趣的是,39%的外科医生为所谓的儿科患者(<18岁)提供腹腔镜肥胖症手术。其中,76%倾向于LAGB,8%倾向于LRYGBP,8%倾向于L-BPD,4%倾向于其他手术。
总体而言,受访者更喜欢腹腔镜手术。调查结果表明,BMI较低时,限制性手术的趋势更高。然而,随着BMI的增加,联合手术和吸收不良手术更受青睐。至少三分之一的外科医生为18岁以下的患者提供肥胖症手术,其中LAGB更受青睐。