Shinagawa N, Yura J, Ishikawa S, Mashita K, Inukai A, Iwai A, Okubo T
First Department of Surgery, Nagoya City University Medical School, Japan.
Nihon Geka Gakkai Zasshi. 1992 Feb;93(2):162-8.
A prospective randomized trial has compared 3 policies of antibiotic prophylaxis in biliary surgery. Patients considered to be high-risked against postoperative infection were randomly allocated to 2 groups: in group CTM-H, patients were given cefotiam; in group CMX-H, patients were given cefmenoxime. Patients free of risk factors (group CTM-L) were all given cefotiam. The high-risk factors adopted in this trial were; emergency surgery, presence of jaundice or cirrhosis, malignant disease, diabetes mellitus, age over 70, recent biliary tract infection, choledocholithiasis, and previous biliary surgery. Postoperative infection occurred in 2.1% (4/190) in the CTM-L group, which was lower compared to 15.5% (11/71) of the CMT-H group (p less than 0.01), and 11.3% (8/71) of the CTM-H group (p less than 0.01). The rates of bacterial isolation from intraoperative bile culture and wound swab were significantly high in the two high-risk groups compared to the low-risk group, but is was not different within the two high-risk groups. These findings suggest that while cefotiam is appropriate for prophylaxis for the low-risk patients, the utmost care should be taken in the high-risk patients to prevent intraoperative contamination along with prophylactic antibiotic therapy which covers the bacteria isolated from the bile.
一项前瞻性随机试验比较了胆道手术中3种抗生素预防策略。被认为术后感染高风险的患者被随机分为2组:在CTM-H组,患者给予头孢替安;在CMX-H组,患者给予头孢甲肟。无危险因素的患者(CTM-L组)均给予头孢替安。本试验采用的高风险因素为:急诊手术、黄疸或肝硬化、恶性疾病、糖尿病、70岁以上、近期胆道感染、胆总管结石和既往胆道手术。CTM-L组术后感染发生率为2.1%(4/190),低于CMT-H组的15.5%(11/71)(p<0.01)和CTM-H组的11.3%(8/71)(p<0.01)。与低风险组相比,两个高风险组术中胆汁培养和伤口拭子细菌分离率显著较高,但两个高风险组之间无差异。这些发现表明,虽然头孢替安适用于低风险患者的预防,但对于高风险患者应格外小心,以防止术中污染,并采用覆盖从胆汁中分离出的细菌的预防性抗生素治疗。