Smith E J, Hussain A, Manoharan M, Testa H J, Curzen N P
Department of Cardiology, Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester M13 9WL, England.
Int J Cardiovasc Imaging. 2004 Aug;20(4):321-6. doi: 10.1023/b:caim.0000041951.48335.1a.
A reverse redistribution pattern during myocardial perfusion imaging is most widely described using thallium (Tl-201), when stress images exhibit greater perfusion than rest. Technetium (Tc-99 m) radiopharmaceuticals may also yield a reverse perfusion (RP) pattern, but its significance is uncertain. This study tested the hypothesis that RP correlates with the presence and location of flow limiting coronary stenosis(es).
We reviewed 842 consecutive Tc-99 m tetrofosmin SPECT stress studies performed at a cardiothoracic centre over a 15 month period. 69 (8.2%) demonstrated RP. Thirty-three patients (age 32-79 mean 56, 17 female) had undergone cardiac catheterisation within 12 months of the scan. Correlation was sought between the presence and location of angiographic stenoses and RP pattern.
10/33 (30.3%) had significant (>60%) coronary stenosis(es); 5 single-vessel, 2 two-vessel and 3 three-vessel disease (3VD). Stenosis location correlated poorly with the RP territory (LAD/Anterior 5/17, RCA/Inferior 1/10, Cx/lateral 0/4 (p = 0.57)). Of the 6 patients with a lesion in the RP territory, 3 had 3VD; 2 of these had a simultaneous reversible defect. All 5 patients with previous myocardial infarction had a simultaneous fixed defect. However only 3/12 with co-existent reversible defects had significant disease.
The reverse perfusion pattern is a poor predictor of flow limiting coronary disease, and does not correlate with stenosis location in those with significant lesions. Such patients should not undergo invasive investigation purely on the basis of this result.
心肌灌注成像期间的反向再分布模式最常使用铊(Tl-201)来描述,此时负荷图像显示的灌注大于静息图像。锝(Tc-99m)放射性药物也可能产生反向灌注(RP)模式,但其意义尚不确定。本研究检验了RP与血流限制性冠状动脉狭窄的存在及位置相关的假说。
我们回顾了在一个心胸中心15个月期间连续进行的842例Tc-99m替曲膦单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT)负荷研究。69例(8.2%)显示有RP。33例患者(年龄32 - 79岁,平均56岁,17例女性)在扫描后12个月内接受了心导管检查。研究了血管造影狭窄的存在及位置与RP模式之间的相关性。
33例中有10例(30.3%)存在显著(>60%)冠状动脉狭窄;5例单支血管病变,2例双支血管病变和3例三支血管病变(3VD)。狭窄位置与RP区域相关性较差(左前降支/前壁5/17,右冠状动脉/下壁1/10,回旋支/侧壁0/4(p = 0.57))。在RP区域有病变的6例患者中,3例有3VD;其中2例同时存在可逆性缺损。所有5例既往有心肌梗死的患者均有同时存在的固定性缺损。然而,在12例同时存在可逆性缺损的患者中,只有3例有显著病变。
反向灌注模式对血流限制性冠状动脉疾病的预测价值较差,且与有显著病变患者的狭窄位置无关。此类患者不应单纯基于此结果而接受有创检查。