Boe J, Kongerud J, Bodd E
Lungeavdelingen Rikshospitalet Oslo.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1992 Feb 20;112(5):661-3.
Retrospective case-control studies suggest a connection between chronic treatment with fenoterol and other beta-2-agonists and increased mortality from asthma. These studies are extremely difficult to assess from a methodological point of view. They raise important questions, however, and force us to critically reevaluate our present therapeutic approach. In the acute situation, beta-2-agonists might be life-saving, and we must therefore be cautious in readily accepting a causal relationship between beta-2-agonist treatment and death from asthma. Probably, retrospective case-control studies are inadequate to establish a clear-cut association between beta-2-agonist therapy and death from asthma. This will require prospective randomized studies including large asthma populations providing accurate information on both chronic and acute drug treatment, and the end-point is death from asthma.
回顾性病例对照研究表明,非诺特罗和其他β2受体激动剂的长期治疗与哮喘死亡率增加之间存在联系。从方法论的角度来看,这些研究极难评估。然而,它们提出了重要问题,并迫使我们批判性地重新评估我们目前的治疗方法。在急性情况下,β2受体激动剂可能挽救生命,因此我们在轻易接受β2受体激动剂治疗与哮喘死亡之间的因果关系时必须谨慎。回顾性病例对照研究可能不足以明确β2受体激动剂治疗与哮喘死亡之间的关联。这将需要进行前瞻性随机研究,纳入大量哮喘患者群体,提供关于慢性和急性药物治疗的准确信息,且终点为哮喘死亡。