Steinert T, Plewe B
Zentrum für Psychiatrie Die Weissenau, Abt. Psychiatrie I, Universität Ulm, Ravensburg-Weissenau.
Nervenarzt. 2005 Jan;76(1):93-102. doi: 10.1007/s00115-004-1845-x.
By analysing the complete edition of the German-language psychiatric journal "Der Nervenarzt" from 1928 to 2000 we examined basic trends in the historical and scientific orientation of psychiatry in this journal. All published articles (n=3270) were classified under formal aspects and were assigned to one of 30 categories by content. Inter-rater reliability was determined in 3 years from different eras (1957, 1977, 1997). With kappa values between 0.65 and 0.81 the inter-rater reliability was moderate to good. The mean number of authors and the mean number of references in the articles has been increasing continuously, particularly within the last decade. The mean number of words per article has been relatively constant. In nearly all 5-year periods, most of the articles came from Heidelberg, Munich and Berlin. In addition to original articles, review articles were introduced in 1971 and medical education articles in 1978. Since 1955 the "Nervenarzt" has been publishing the communications of the German Psychiatric and Neurological Society. Original articles with data reports and articles using statistics have been increasing continuously since the 1960s, reflecting an increasing evidence-based orientation of psychiatry. The currently accepted scientific standard was introduced in the early 1990s. The last decade, the "decade of the brain", not only yielded a high proportion of articles on biological issues but also indicated an increasing interest in institutions of psychiatric care and psychotherapy. On the other hand, links to related disciplines such as philosophy, sociology and psychology seem to have got lost. The percentage of articles from abroad has been decreasing within the last 2 decades. In comparison, the American Journal of Psychiatry, the Archives of General Psychiatry and the British Journal of Psychiatry have been publishing a higher percentage of original articles, particularly randomised controlled trials.
通过分析1928年至2000年德语精神病学杂志《神经科医生》的完整版本,我们研究了该杂志中精神病学历史和科学导向的基本趋势。所有发表的文章(n = 3270)按照形式方面进行分类,并根据内容分配到30个类别之一。在不同时期(1957年、1977年、1997年)的3年中确定了评分者间信度。评分者间信度的kappa值在0.65至0.81之间,为中等至良好。文章的平均作者数量和平均参考文献数量一直在持续增加,特别是在过去十年中。每篇文章的平均字数相对稳定。在几乎所有的5年时间段内,大多数文章来自海德堡、慕尼黑和柏林。除了原创文章外,1971年引入了综述文章,1978年引入了医学教育文章。自1955年以来,《神经科医生》一直发表德国精神病学和神经学学会的通讯。自20世纪60年代以来,带有数据报告的原创文章和使用统计学的文章一直在持续增加,这反映了精神病学越来越以证据为导向。目前被接受的科学标准是在20世纪90年代初引入的。过去十年,即“大脑的十年”,不仅产生了高比例的关于生物学问题的文章,还表明对精神病护理机构和心理治疗的兴趣日益增加。另一方面,与哲学、社会学和心理学等相关学科的联系似乎已经丧失。在过去20年中,来自国外的文章百分比一直在下降。相比之下,《美国精神病学杂志》《普通精神病学档案》和《英国精神病学杂志》发表的原创文章比例更高,特别是随机对照试验。