O'Connor Shannon L, Bender Bruce G, Gavin-Devitt Leslie A, Wamboldt Marianne Z, Milgrom Henry, Szefler Stanley, Rand Cynthia, Wamboldt Frederick S
National Jewish Medical and Research Center, Denver, Colorado, USA.
J Asthma. 2004 Sep;41(6):663-70. doi: 10.1081/jas-200026434.
Non-adherence with prescribed asthma treatment causes compromised treatment effectiveness, including greater morbidity, mortality, and health care utilization costs. As a result, there is an increasing interest in measuring patient adherence behaviors. Electronic monitoring devices offer a promising method for assessing patient adherence behavior patterns. The reliability of the Doser Clinical Trials (CT) (Meditrack Products, Hudson, MA), an inexpensive, pressure-actuated device that monitors metered-dose inhaler (MDI) usage, was evaluated in a field study of outpatient pediatric asthmatics. Canister weight and various Doser CT measures of patient medication use were compared to determine the reliability and usefulness of the device. Doser CTs were dispensed to 16 research subjects for use on corticosteroid MDIs over a period of several months. One Doser CT per month was dispensed to each subject. Doser CTs were collected at 30-60 day intervals, with a total of 61 months of Doser CT data obtained across the subjects. MDI canister weights were monitored for a subset of 6 subjects. Usable Doser CT data were summarized and average adherence estimates were computed. Adherence estimates differed from one another and the adherence estimate, as measured by canister weight, was significantly higher than each Doser CT estimate. However, overall, the Doser CT showed adequate reliability as evidenced by high correlations among the Doser CT estimates of adherence and the existing gold standard of canister weight. The Doser CT is likely to be useful for monitoring MDI use in clinical care and research, potentially providing greater accuracy than the standard of canister weight.
不遵守哮喘治疗方案会导致治疗效果受损,包括更高的发病率、死亡率以及医疗保健使用成本。因此,人们对衡量患者的依从行为越来越感兴趣。电子监测设备为评估患者的依从行为模式提供了一种很有前景的方法。在一项针对门诊儿科哮喘患者的实地研究中,对剂量计临床试验(CT)(Meditrack Products公司,马萨诸塞州哈德逊)的可靠性进行了评估,该设备是一种价格低廉的压力驱动装置,用于监测定量吸入器(MDI)的使用情况。比较了药罐重量和剂量计CT对患者用药的各种测量结果,以确定该设备的可靠性和实用性。向16名研究对象发放了剂量计CT,用于在几个月的时间里监测皮质类固醇MDI的使用情况。每月向每位研究对象发放一个剂量计CT。每隔30至60天收集一次剂量计CT,共获得了61个月的剂量计CT数据,覆盖了所有研究对象。对6名研究对象的一个子集监测了MDI药罐的重量。对可用的剂量计CT数据进行了总结,并计算了平均依从性估计值。不同的依从性估计值之间存在差异,并且通过药罐重量测量的依从性估计值显著高于每个剂量计CT的估计值。然而,总体而言,剂量计CT显示出足够的可靠性,这体现在剂量计CT的依从性估计值与现有的药罐重量金标准之间的高度相关性上。剂量计CT可能有助于监测临床护理和研究中MDI的使用情况,其准确性可能高于药罐重量这一标准。