Simmons M S, Nides M A, Kleerup E C, Chapman K R, Milgrom H, Rand C S, Spector S L, Tashkin D P
UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, Calif 90095-1690, USA.
J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1998 Sep;102(3):409-13. doi: 10.1016/s0091-6749(98)70128-9.
Electronic monitoring of medication use has proved valuable in both clinical and research settings. The Doser, a new and inexpensive commercially available device for monitoring metered-dose inhaler (MDI) use, displays 3 measures of daily use of an attached MDI: (1) the daily total of actuations, (2) the number of doses remaining in the MDI, and (3) the number of actuations on each of the preceding 30 days for later recall.
We sought to validate the accuracy of the Doser with several commonly prescribed MDIs.
In the laboratory, clinic personnel actuated an MDI with an attached Doser several times in succession on 3 consecutive days and recorded each of the 3 measures of MDI use (study 1). In study 2 clinic personnel carried an MDI and attached Doser with them for 4 weeks, actuating the MDI according to a prescribed protocol each morning and evening and again recording each of the 3 measures of daily use. In addition, during 2 weeks of study 2, a thermistor-based Nebulizer Chronolog was attached to the MDI to electronically record the date and time of each actuation. In study 3 clinic patients had both a Doser and Nebulizer Chronolog attached to their routinely used inhalers for 2 weeks and a Doser alone during a separate 2-week period.
In study 1 agreement was 99% to 100% among the 3 Doser measures, and each measure agreed with actual use by self-report 97% of the time. In study 2 agreement among the 3 Doser measures of use ranged from 98% to 99%. Agreement between each of the 3 Doser measures and the Nebulizer Chronolog ranged from 90% to 93%. Agreement between each of the 3 Doser measures and actual use ranged from 96% to 97%, and the Nebulizer Chronolog agreed with actual use 93% of the time. In study 3 Doser and Nebulizer Chronolog agreement with patient self-report were 85% and 80%, respectively. Agreement between the Doser and Nebulizer Chronolog was 76%. Several failures of the thermistor-based Nebulizer Chronolog occurred, and occasional mechanical problems occurred with the Doser, primarily on particular types of MDI canisters.
The Doser provides an accurate measure of MDI use with most commonly prescribed medications and may be useful for monitoring MDI use by investigators, clinicians, and patients.
药物使用的电子监测在临床和研究环境中均已证明具有重要价值。剂量仪是一种新型且价格低廉的市售设备,用于监测定量吸入器(MDI)的使用情况,它可显示所连接MDI的三项每日使用指标:(1)每日总启动次数;(2)MDI中剩余的剂量数;(3)前30天中每天的启动次数,以便日后查阅。
我们试图验证剂量仪与几种常用MDI的准确性。
在实验室中,临床工作人员连续3天每天多次使用连接有剂量仪的MDI,并记录MDI使用的三项指标(研究1)。在研究2中,临床工作人员携带连接有剂量仪的MDI 4周,按照规定方案每天早晚启动MDI,并再次记录三项每日使用指标。此外,在研究2的2周内,将基于热敏电阻的雾化器计时仪连接到MDI上,以电子方式记录每次启动的日期和时间。在研究3中,临床患者在2周内将剂量仪和雾化器计时仪都连接到其常规使用的吸入器上,并在另一个单独的2周期间仅连接剂量仪。
在研究1中,剂量仪的三项指标之间的一致性为99%至100%,且每项指标与自我报告的实际使用情况相符的时间为97%。在研究2中,三项剂量仪使用指标之间的一致性范围为98%至99%。剂量仪的三项指标与雾化器计时仪之间的一致性范围为90%至93%。剂量仪的三项指标与实际使用情况之间的一致性范围为96%至97%,雾化器计时仪与实际使用情况相符的时间为93%。在研究3中,剂量仪和雾化器计时仪与患者自我报告的一致性分别为85%和80%。剂量仪与雾化器计时仪之间的一致性为76%。基于热敏电阻的雾化器计时仪出现了几次故障,剂量仪偶尔也出现机械问题,主要是在特定类型的MDI药罐上。
剂量仪能准确测量大多数常用药物的MDI使用情况,可能对研究人员、临床医生和患者监测MDI使用情况有用。