Folayan M O, Idehen E E, Ojo O O
Department of Preventive Dentistry, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife, Nigeria.
Eur J Paediatr Dent. 2004 Dec;5(4):225-32.
To investigate the effects and interrelationship between dental anxiety and dentist's experience, dentist's behaviour, type of treatment received and the behaviour of Nigerian children during treatment.
Pre- and post-dental treatment anxiety levels of 69 child patients, who were attending the dental clinic to receive dental treatment for the first time, were assessed using the DFSS-SF. The dentist's and child's behaviour during treatment procedures were unobtrusively observed and recorded. The pre- treatment anxiety levels were classified as high (HAC) and low (LAC), while those of the dentists who managed the children were categorized as experience or inexperienced. The interrelationship between a child's dental anxiety level, dentist's behaviour during child management, dentist's experience and the type of treatment the child received were analysed.
The anxiety level of the children decreased significantly post-treatment when experienced dentists managed the child in comparison to inexperienced dentists (Z=3.22, p<0.02). The dentist's behaviour did not significantly affect the anxiety level of the child. However, physical contact was used more frequently with HAC than LAC (z=2.27;p<0.023). There was no association between a child's behaviour in the dental chair and their anxiety level (chi(2)=0.08, p<0.93). Also, the more invasive the procedure, the less the tendency for a noted decrease in anxiety level of a child post-treatment, though this was statistically insignificant (z=1.34; p<0.44).
The dentist's behaviour played no role in changing the anxiety level of a child nor did it have any influence on anxiety-related behaviour of a child. However, the experience of the dentist was a very significant factor for effecting a decrease in the dental anxiety level change for children.
探讨牙科焦虑与牙医经验、牙医行为、接受的治疗类型以及尼日利亚儿童治疗期间行为之间的影响及相互关系。
使用牙科恐惧量表简版(DFSS-SF)评估69名首次到牙科诊所接受治疗的儿童患者治疗前和治疗后的牙科焦虑水平。在治疗过程中对牙医和儿童的行为进行不引人注意的观察和记录。治疗前的焦虑水平分为高(HAC)和低(LAC),而负责治疗儿童的牙医则分为经验丰富或经验不足。分析儿童的牙科焦虑水平、儿童治疗期间牙医的行为、牙医经验以及儿童接受的治疗类型之间的相互关系。
与经验不足的牙医相比,经验丰富的牙医治疗儿童时,儿童治疗后的焦虑水平显著降低(Z=3.22,p<0.02)。牙医的行为对儿童的焦虑水平没有显著影响。然而,与低焦虑儿童相比,高焦虑儿童接受身体接触的频率更高(z=2.27;p<0.023)。儿童在牙科治疗椅上的行为与其焦虑水平之间没有关联(卡方=0.08,p<0.93)。此外,治疗程序侵入性越强,儿童治疗后焦虑水平下降的趋势越小,尽管这在统计学上不显著(z=1.34;p<0.44)。
牙医的行为在改变儿童焦虑水平方面没有作用,对儿童与焦虑相关的行为也没有任何影响。然而,牙医的经验是影响儿童牙科焦虑水平降低的一个非常重要的因素。