Cho Keun Tae, Lee Dong Yeob, Chung Chun Kee, Han Moon Hee, Kim Hyun Jib
Department of Neurosurgery, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Neurosurgery. 2005 Feb;56(2):232-41; discussion 232-41. doi: 10.1227/01.neu.0000147974.79671.83.
To provide the optimal treatment strategy for perimedullary arteriovenous fistula (PMAVF).
Nineteen patients with PMAVF (Type IVa in 9 patients, Type IVb in 6, and Type IVc in 4) were treated at Seoul National University Hospital between January 1988 and March 2001. Their mean age was 28 years (range, 6-52 yr), and the male-to-female ratio was 1.7:1. The mean follow-up period was 20 months (range, 2-55 mo). Most patients presented with symptoms of slowly progressive myelopathy (13 patients). On spinal angiography, all but 2 showed fistula at the level of the conus medullaris. The feeder was the anterior spinal artery and/or the posterior spinal artery in 14 patients and the posterior spinal artery in 5. All patients underwent endovascular or surgical treatment.
With endovascular treatment (11 patients; IVa, n = 5; IVb, n = 2; IVc, n = 4), complete angiographic obliteration of fistula was performed in 5 and partial obliteration in 4 (IVa, n = 1; IVb, n = 2; IVc, n = 1). Symptomatic improvement or arrest of progression was achieved in 5 of 9 patients with complete or partial occlusion. Embolization failed in two (IVa, n = 1; IVc, n = 1). With surgery (10 patients [IVa, n = 6; IVb, n = 4], including 2 patients with partial or failed embolization), most (9 of 10) were improved or stable.
Good results were achieved with surgery for Types IVa and IVb PMAVF located at the level of the conus medullaris. For Type IVc PMAVF, a fistula located on the ventral side of the spinal cord or above the conus medullaris, endovascular treatment might be considered. Because of rapidly evolving endovascular techniques, however, further studies are warranted.
为脊髓周围动静脉瘘(PMAVF)提供最佳治疗策略。
1988年1月至2001年3月期间,首尔国立大学医院对19例PMAVF患者进行了治疗(9例为IVa型,6例为IVb型,4例为IVc型)。他们的平均年龄为28岁(范围6 - 52岁),男女比例为1.7:1。平均随访期为20个月(范围2 - 55个月)。大多数患者表现为缓慢进展性脊髓病症状(13例患者)。在脊髓血管造影中,除2例患者外,其余均显示在脊髓圆锥水平存在瘘管。14例患者的供血动脉为脊髓前动脉和/或脊髓后动脉,5例患者的供血动脉为脊髓后动脉。所有患者均接受了血管内或手术治疗。
采用血管内治疗(11例患者;IVa型5例,IVb型2例,IVc型4例),5例患者瘘管造影完全闭塞,4例部分闭塞(IVa型1例,IVb型2例,IVc型1例)。9例完全或部分闭塞的患者中有5例症状改善或病情进展停止。2例栓塞失败(IVa型1例,IVc型1例)。采用手术治疗(10例患者[IVa型6例,IVb型4例],包括2例部分栓塞或栓塞失败的患者),大多数(10例中的9例)病情改善或稳定。
对于位于脊髓圆锥水平的IVa型和IVb型PMAVF,手术取得了良好效果。对于IVc型PMAVF,即位于脊髓腹侧或脊髓圆锥上方的瘘管,可考虑血管内治疗。然而,由于血管内技术的快速发展,仍需进一步研究。