Verrall Geoffrey M, Slavotinek John P, Barnes Peter G, Fon Gerald T
SPORTSMED SA Sports Medicine Clinic, Adelaide, Australia.
Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2005 Feb;15(1):36-42. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0838.2004.00380.x.
The clinical assessment of groin pain in athletes is difficult, with the lack of specific clinical tests being in part responsible. Three pain provocation tests used in the diagnosis of chronic groin pain are described and their relationship to defined clinical and MRI criteria has been assessed. Eighty-nine Australian Rules football players with and without groin symptoms underwent clinical examination followed by history. Three pain provocation tests were performed (named as the Single Adductor, Squeeze and Bilateral Adductor tests). All athletes subsequently underwent MRI of their groin region for the presence of significant pubic bone marrow oedema (BMO). Of the 89, 47 were defined as having chronic groin pain, and 46 had significant BMO with 37 having both chronic groin pain and BMO. The three pain provocation tests demonstrated only moderate sensitivity (range 30-65%). Positive predictive values were moderate to high (67-93%) depending upon the individual test. The Bilateral Adductor test was the most sensitive test with the highest positive predictive values. The high specificity (88-93%) demonstrated should be treated with caution due to the study methodology. Three pain provocation tests of potential value in assessing chronic groin pain in athletes are described. If positive, all three pain provocation tests demonstrated a high likelihood for the athlete having MR-detected parasymphyseal pubic BMO. Further research is required on assessing the clinical usefulness of these tests.
对运动员腹股沟疼痛进行临床评估颇具难度,部分原因在于缺乏特定的临床检查方法。本文描述了三种用于诊断慢性腹股沟疼痛的激发试验,并评估了它们与既定临床及MRI标准之间的关系。89名有或无腹股沟症状的澳大利亚式橄榄球运动员先接受了临床检查,随后进行了病史询问。进行了三种激发试验(分别命名为单内收肌试验、挤压试验和双侧内收肌试验)。所有运动员随后都接受了腹股沟区域的MRI检查,以确定是否存在明显的耻骨骨髓水肿(BMO)。在这89名运动员中,47名被定义为患有慢性腹股沟疼痛,46名有明显的BMO,其中37名既有慢性腹股沟疼痛又有BMO。这三种激发试验的敏感性仅为中等(范围为30 - 65%)。根据具体试验不同,阳性预测值为中等至高(67 - 93%)。双侧内收肌试验是最敏感的试验,阳性预测值最高。鉴于研究方法的原因,所显示的高特异性(88 - 93%)应谨慎看待。本文描述了三种对评估运动员慢性腹股沟疼痛可能有价值的激发试验。如果试验结果为阳性,所有这三种激发试验都表明运动员很可能存在MRI检测到的耻骨联合旁骨髓水肿。需要进一步研究以评估这些试验的临床实用性。