Straub R, Wolfersdorf M, Keller F, Hole G
Abteilung Psychiatrie I, Universität Ulm.
Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr. 1992 Feb;60(2):45-53. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-999123.
From a psychological point of view, we would expect that motivational rather than biological dysfunctions mediate initiation of violent and non-violent suicidal actions. To prove this assumption we classified depressed women in four groups according to their suicidal behaviour and matched them to age: suicide ideators, violent suicide attempters, non-violent suicide attempters, non-suicidal depressed controls. We then tested group differences in respect of aggression, impulsivity, introversion, affective lability, anxiety, depression and electrodermal activity (EDA). To take a closer look at motivational dysfunctions, we implemented the Action Control Scale (corresponding to Kuhls theory of action and state orientation), since we regard chronic state orientation as a risk factor for suicidal behaviour. Results show few differences in violent attempters compared with controls. In contrast to non-violent attempters, they show a greater tendency to achievement and action oriented behaviour being less introverted. Non-violent attempters, however, show most significant differences to their controls: Corresponding to a high state orientation, they are more depressed, anxious, less stable in respect of affectiveness, and more introverted, with low scores in aggression and contentedness in life. In contrast to some other studies, nonreactivity in the electrodermal system dominates in all groups. Results demonstrate that motivational dysfunctions like state orientation allow better prediction and understanding of violent or non-violent suicidal behaviour in depressed women than does electrodermal reactivity.
从心理学角度来看,我们预期动机功能障碍而非生物功能障碍介导了暴力和非暴力自杀行为的发生。为了证明这一假设,我们根据抑郁女性的自杀行为将她们分为四组,并按照年龄进行匹配:自杀意念者、暴力自杀未遂者、非暴力自杀未遂者、非自杀性抑郁对照组。然后,我们测试了四组在攻击性、冲动性、内向性、情感不稳定性、焦虑、抑郁和皮肤电活动(EDA)方面的差异。为了更深入地研究动机功能障碍,我们采用了行动控制量表(对应于库尔的行动与状态取向理论),因为我们认为长期的状态取向是自杀行为的一个风险因素。结果显示,与对照组相比,暴力未遂者之间差异不大。与非暴力未遂者相比,他们表现出更强的成就倾向和行动导向行为,内向性较低。然而,非暴力未遂者与对照组相比差异最为显著:与高状态取向一致,他们更抑郁、焦虑,情感稳定性较差,更内向,攻击性得分较低,生活满意度也较低。与其他一些研究不同的是,皮肤电系统的无反应性在所有组中都占主导地位。结果表明,与皮肤电反应性相比,像状态取向这样的动机功能障碍能更好地预测和理解抑郁女性的暴力或非暴力自杀行为。