Chen Chen-Sheng, Feng Chi-Kuang, Cheng Cheng-Kung, Tzeng Ming-Ji, Liu Chien-Lin, Chen Wen-Jer
Institute of Rehabilitation Science and Technology, National Yang-Ming University, 155 Sec. 2 Li-Nung Street, Taipei, Taiwan.
J Spinal Disord Tech. 2005 Feb;18(1):58-65. doi: 10.1097/01.bsd.0000123426.12852.e7.
After posterolateral fusion with laminectomy for the degenerative lumbar spine, accelerated degeneration of the disc adjacent to the fusion mass has been clinically observed. Previous studies used a finite element model (FEM) to calculate the stress of the adjacent disc in the fused lumbar spine with spinal fixator and bone graft. However, little emphasis was placed on the simultaneous spinal fusion and decompression procedure. To investigate if the spinal decompression procedure in posterolateral fusion would increase stress significantly, the FEM was employed to estimate the stress concentration of the disc above the fusion mass in posterolateral fusion with laminectomy and hemilaminectomy.
Three FEMs of the lumbar spine were established: intact spine, posterolateral fusion with total laminectomy, and posterolateral fusion with hemilaminectomy (preserved partial lamina, spinous process, and supraspinous and interspinous ligaments). The posterolateral fusion added spinal fixator and bone graft between the transverse process. The L1 vertebral body was subjected to 10-Nm flexion, extension, torsion, and lateral bending. The bottom of the L5 vertebral body was fixed.
In flexion, the stress on the adjacent disc in posterolateral fusion with laminectomy and hemilaminectomy respectively increased 90% and 21% over that of the intact spine. In posterolateral fusion with hemilaminectomy, the supraspinous and interspinous ligaments shared some external forces to alleviate the stress concentration of the adjacent disc. However, in extension, torsion, and lateral bending, these two fusion models had almost no change in range of motion and stress of adjacent disc.
Posterolateral fusion with hemilaminectomy (preserved partial lamina, spinous process, and supraspinous and interspinous ligaments) was able to alleviate the stress concentration of the disc above the fusion mass in flexion.
在对退变性腰椎行后外侧融合并椎板切除术后,临床上观察到融合块相邻椎间盘加速退变。以往研究使用有限元模型(FEM)计算脊柱固定器和植骨的融合腰椎中相邻椎间盘的应力。然而,对同时进行的脊柱融合与减压手术关注较少。为研究后外侧融合术中的脊柱减压手术是否会显著增加应力,采用有限元模型来估计在椎板切除和半椎板切除的后外侧融合术中融合块上方椎间盘的应力集中情况。
建立三个腰椎有限元模型:完整脊柱、全椎板切除的后外侧融合以及半椎板切除的后外侧融合(保留部分椎板、棘突以及棘上和棘间韧带)。后外侧融合在横突间增加了脊柱固定器和植骨。对L1椎体施加10 N·m的前屈、后伸、扭转和侧方弯曲。L5椎体底部固定。
在前屈时,椎板切除和半椎板切除的后外侧融合中相邻椎间盘的应力分别比完整脊柱增加了90%和21%。在半椎板切除的后外侧融合中,棘上和棘间韧带分担了一些外力,以减轻相邻椎间盘的应力集中。然而,在后伸、扭转和侧方弯曲时,这两种融合模型在相邻椎间盘的活动范围和应力方面几乎没有变化。
半椎板切除的后外侧融合(保留部分椎板、棘突以及棘上和棘间韧带)能够减轻前屈时融合块上方椎间盘的应力集中。