Gratzer Walter
Randall Division, King's College, New Hunt's House, Guy's Campus, London SE1 1UL, Royaume-Uni.
Med Sci (Paris). 2005 Feb;21(2):203-6. doi: 10.1051/medsci/2005212203.
Trofim Lysenko was a Ukrainian peasant whose malign influence dominated biology in the Soviet Union and its imperium through most of Stalin's reign. Lysenko owed his ascendancy to repeated promises that he would rescue Soviet agriculture from the catastrophic state into which it had sunk, following Stalin's disastrous policy of collectivisation of the farms, and a succession of bad harvests. He claimed to have devised methods of imposing desirable hereditary characteristics on plants, and even of converting one species into another at will. He noisily denounced modern genetics as a bourgeois imposture, a view that resonated well with Marxist doctrine. As Lysenko's power grew he was able to smother scientific debate, and to crush all opposition through the arrest and often execution of many leading scientists. Lysenko's preposterous theories became the accepted orthodoxy in the academies and universities of Eastern Europe, and were greeted with enthusiasm by many Communist intellectuals in the West, not least in France. The Lysenko phenomenon is the most extreme, but by no means the only example of the perversion of science by ideology, often with the acquiescence of the scientific community. Nor can we be confident that nothing of the kind could happen today.
特罗菲姆·李森科是一名乌克兰农民,在斯大林统治的大部分时间里,他的恶劣影响主宰了苏联及其帝国的生物学领域。李森科的崛起得益于他一再承诺,会将苏联农业从灾难性状态中拯救出来。苏联农业在斯大林灾难性的农场集体化政策以及一连串歉收之后陷入了这种状态。他声称自己设计出了一些方法,可以将理想的遗传特征强加给植物,甚至能随意将一个物种变成另一个物种。他大肆抨击现代遗传学是资产阶级的骗局,这一观点与马克思主义学说高度契合。随着李森科权力的增长,他得以压制科学辩论,并通过逮捕甚至处决许多顶尖科学家来打压所有反对意见。李森科那些荒谬的理论在东欧的科学院和大学里成了公认的正统学说,在西方,尤其是在法国,受到了许多共产党知识分子的热烈欢迎。李森科现象是意识形态扭曲科学的最极端例子,但绝不是唯一的例子,而且这种情况往往在科学界的默认下发生。我们也不能确定如今不会发生类似的事情。