Farber Mitchell S, Moses Julia, Korn Margaret
Department of Trauma and Surgical Critical Care, Hurley Medical Center, Michigan State University College of Human Medicine, Flint, Michigan, USA.
JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr. 2005 Jan-Feb;29(1 Suppl):S62-9. doi: 10.1177/01486071050290S1S62.
Critically ill patients are at high risk for nosocomial infections and resultant organ dysfunction and death. These patients typically have protracted intensive care unit (ICU) courses and consume increasingly limited resources. Enteral nutrition with specific immune-modulating components has been previously shown to improve outcomes in select populations of patients, but results have been mixed in critically ill patients. Impact 1.5 (Novartis Nutrition, Minneapolis, MN) is a commercially available enteral formula containing ingredients known to improve several parameters of immune function. We hypothesized that administration of Impact 1.5 tube feedings would reduce the incidence of nosocomial infection and ICU resources in critically ill patients admitted to the ICU for severe trauma, burns, or sepsis insults.
The Impact 1.5 group (n = 17) was compared with a historical cohort of ICU patients (n = 21) of similar illness severity that received a standard high-energy enteral formula. The incidence of nosocomial infections and mortality, and the consumption of multiple ICU resources were examined. A cost analysis based on these results was then performed to determine the cost effectiveness of this proprietary immunonutrition enteral formula.
A pronounced reduction in nosocomial pneumonia (12% vs 52%, p < .01) was identified, with consequent trends toward a reduction in duration of mechanical ventilation and ICU length of stay. Urinary tract infections that may have less influence on ICU resources were increased in the Impact 1.5 group. No difference in mortality was identified, despite the inclusion of patients with severe sepsis in the study group. According to the average number of ICU days required for each study cohort, the Impact 1.5 group led to a cost savings of at least $193,350.00.
ICU patients with significant illness severity experienced a decrease in the incidence of an important nosocomial infection that is commonly associated with increased use of ICU resources and length of stay. This decrease in patient morbidity led to substantial cost savings despite the small size of our study trial.
重症患者发生医院感染以及由此导致器官功能障碍和死亡的风险很高。这些患者通常在重症监护病房(ICU)接受长期治疗,消耗的资源日益有限。先前的研究表明,含有特定免疫调节成分的肠内营养可改善部分患者群体的预后,但在重症患者中的结果不一。Impact 1.5(诺华营养,明尼阿波利斯,明尼苏达州)是一种市售肠内配方产品,其所含成分已知可改善免疫功能的多个参数。我们假设,对因严重创伤、烧伤或脓毒症入住ICU的重症患者给予Impact 1.5管饲可降低医院感染的发生率并减少ICU资源的消耗。
将Impact 1.5组(n = 17)与接受标准高能肠内配方产品、疾病严重程度相似的ICU患者历史队列(n = 21)进行比较。检查医院感染的发生率和死亡率,以及多种ICU资源的消耗情况。然后基于这些结果进行成本分析,以确定这种专利免疫营养肠内配方产品的成本效益。
发现医院获得性肺炎显著减少(12%对52%,p <.01),随之机械通气时间和ICU住院时间有缩短趋势。Impact 1.5组中对ICU资源影响可能较小的尿路感染有所增加。尽管研究组纳入了严重脓毒症患者,但未发现死亡率有差异。根据每个研究队列所需的平均ICU天数,Impact 1.5组至少节省了193,350.00美元的成本。
疾病严重程度较高的ICU患者中,一种与ICU资源使用增加和住院时间延长通常相关的重要医院感染的发生率有所降低。尽管我们的研究样本量较小,但患者发病率的降低带来了可观的成本节省。