Kaneko S, Otani K, Kondo T, Fukushima Y, Nakamura Y, Ogawa Y, Kan R, Takeda A, Nakane Y, Teranishi T
Department of Neuropsychiatry, Hirosaki University Hospital, Japan.
Neurology. 1992 Apr;42(4 Suppl 5):68-74.
To assess the relative contribution of antiepileptic drugs (AEDS) to occurrence of congenital malformations, we compared two prospective studies. We analyzed data for 14 AEDs for total daily doses (drug score) and eight background factors. From the first study, the drug score and polytherapy--particularly the use of valproate plus carbamazepine--were suspected to be primary factors for increased incidence of congenital malformation. In the other study, the drug score for each case was decreased, and polytherapy--particularly valproate plus carbamazepine--was changed to monotherapy before conception. These changes significantly decreased the incidence of malformations. Among risk factors, only the doses of methylphenobarbital for mothers of infants with malformations were significantly higher than those for mothers of infants without malformations. Statistical differences were seen in drug score, number of AEDs, maternal age at delivery, seizure type, and etiology of epilepsy between the two groups. When data were corrected for seizure type, maternal age at delivery, or etiology of epilepsy, the difference in the incidence of malformations did not disappear, but it did disappear when data were corrected for drug score or number of AEDs. These results support our previous observations that AEDs are primary factors for the increased incidence of congenital malformation in infants of mothers with epilepsy.
为评估抗癫痫药物(AEDs)对先天性畸形发生的相对影响,我们比较了两项前瞻性研究。我们分析了14种AEDs的每日总剂量(药物评分)及八个背景因素的数据。在第一项研究中,药物评分和联合用药——尤其是丙戊酸盐加卡马西平的使用——被怀疑是先天性畸形发生率增加的主要因素。在另一项研究中,每个病例的药物评分降低,并且联合用药——尤其是丙戊酸盐加卡马西平——在受孕前改为单一疗法。这些改变显著降低了畸形发生率。在风险因素中,只有畸形婴儿母亲的甲基苯巴比妥剂量显著高于无畸形婴儿母亲的剂量。两组之间在药物评分、AEDs数量、分娩时母亲年龄、癫痫发作类型及癫痫病因方面存在统计学差异。当对癫痫发作类型、分娩时母亲年龄或癫痫病因的数据进行校正时,畸形发生率的差异并未消失,但当对药物评分或AEDs数量的数据进行校正时,差异消失了。这些结果支持了我们之前的观察,即AEDs是癫痫母亲所生婴儿先天性畸形发生率增加的主要因素。