Hasford Joerg, Pfirrmann Markus, Shepherd Pat, Guilhot Joëlle, Hehlmann Rüdiger, Mahon François-Xavier, Kluin-Nelemans Hanneke C, Ohnishi Kazunori, Steegmann Juan Luis, Thaler Josef
Université Victor Ségalen, Bordeaux, France; University Hospital Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Haematologica. 2005 Mar;90(3):335-40.
This study was aimed at examining major cytogenetic response (MCR) as a valid predictor of the course of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) and at assessing the survival of CML patients treated with interferon alpha (IFN) in dependence on the combination of MCR (yes or no) with the baseline risk group of the New CML score. MCR was defined as a reduction of Philadelphia chromosome-positive bone marrow cells to <or= 35%. The New CML score discriminated three risk groups with significantly different survival probabilities.
Data from individual patients with a confirmed diagnosis of Philadelphia chromosome-positive CML treated with IFN were collected from 10 prospective studies in Europe and Japan. Stratified for baseline risk group, patients with a major cytogenetic response by 21 months after the start of therapy (n=171) were compared with patients achieving a minor response or less (n=487). Survival probabilities after the landmark at 21 months were compared by using the two-sided log-rank test.
MCR was a major predictor for low- and intermediate-risk patients (log-rank test, p <or= 0.0001), but not for high-risk patients. Ten-year survival probabilities for the low- and intermediate-risk patients who had a MCR were 75% (95 CI: 65-86%) and 56% (95 CI: 37-75%), respectively. The corresponding probabilities for patients who did not achieve a MCR were 21% (95 CI: 6-35%) and 16% (95 CI: 6-25%).
Cytogenetic response per se is not a valid surrogate marker, as it is dependent on the baseline prognostic profile. The combination of risk group and cytogenetic response does, however, provide useful clinical information. The survival data presented here can serve as a benchmark for the assessment of the long-term effectiveness of imatinib.
本研究旨在检验主要细胞遗传学反应(MCR)作为慢性髓性白血病(CML)病程有效预测指标的作用,并评估接受α干扰素(IFN)治疗的CML患者的生存情况,该评估依赖于MCR(是或否)与新CML评分基线风险组的组合。MCR定义为费城染色体阳性骨髓细胞减少至≤35%。新CML评分区分了三个生存概率显著不同的风险组。
从欧洲和日本的10项前瞻性研究中收集了确诊为费城染色体阳性CML且接受IFN治疗的个体患者数据。根据基线风险组进行分层,比较治疗开始后21个月出现主要细胞遗传学反应的患者(n = 171)与出现微小反应或更小反应的患者(n = 487)。使用双侧对数秩检验比较21个月这个时间节点后的生存概率。
MCR是低风险和中风险患者的主要预测指标(对数秩检验,p≤0.0001),但不是高风险患者的预测指标。有MCR的低风险和中风险患者的10年生存概率分别为75%(95%置信区间:65 - 86%)和56%(95%置信区间:37 - 75%)。未达到MCR的患者相应概率分别为21%(95%置信区间:6 - 35%)和16%(95%置信区间:6 - 25%)。
细胞遗传学反应本身并非有效的替代标志物,因为它依赖于基线预后特征。然而,风险组与细胞遗传学反应的组合确实提供了有用的临床信息。此处呈现的生存数据可作为评估伊马替尼长期疗效的基准。