Schüetz A, Kemkes B M, Breuer M, Brandl U, Engelhardt M, Kugler C, Manz C, Hatz R, Gokel J M, Hammer C
Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, University of Munich-Grosshadern, Federal Republic of Germany.
J Heart Lung Transplant. 1992 Mar-Apr;11(2 Pt 1):289-99; discussion 299-300.
Right cervical, heterotopic heart transplantation was performed in 18 mongrel dogs. Study design was based on three different groups (n = 3 x 6). Standard immunosuppression consisted of triple drug therapy in all dogs. Groups II and III received high dose steroids during acute rejection. In group III the native hearts of previous recipients (groups I and II) were used as donors for heterotopic transplantation ("domino" principle). The hearts were examined by daily transmural biventricular biopsies and graded according to Billingham classification. Cytoimmunologic monitoring (n = 345; activation index from peripheral and coronary sinus blood) and fast Fourier transformation ECG (n = 80; area under the curve; surface recordings) served as daily noninvasive methods. Optionally antimyosin scintigraphy (n = 25; single photon emission computed tomography; heart-to-lung ratio) was performed and immunohistologically confirmed by peroxidase staining of the antibody (n = 61). Kinetics of rejection was not uniform in group I (onset after 5.7 days) and biphasic in group II (clear rejection-free interval: 6.8 days). Group III developed a continuously persisting rejection, despite repeated high-dose steroids, with an early onset (3.2 days). The invasive data, consisting of 587 punch biopsies, showed no significant difference between right and left ventricular rejection. Clearly focal rejection appeared in 51.5% of the cases, with subendocardial involvement in 54%. Cytoimmunologic monitoring significantly (p less than 0.001) correlated with daily biopsies in groups I and II. The activation index from coronary sinus blood was two times higher than in peripheral blood. Fast Fourier transform ECG identified the onset of rejection with great accuracy (p less than 0.01). The heart-to-lung ratio of antimyosin scintigraphy corresponded exactly to the various stages of rejection (p less than 0.001). High-dose steroids led to a clear reduction of the ratio in 26% cases. Peroxidase staining showed typical locations of the antibody, depending on the grade of rejection (p less than 0.001). Considering the results of pathology in this transplantation model, relying on endomyocardial biopsy alone in a clinical setting may not seem advisable. Although the results of this study must be confirmed clinically, the simultaneous use of cytoimmunologic monitoring and fast Fourier transformation ECG may prove to be valuable to day-to-day monitoring for acute rejection in the early postoperative course. If both methods indicate the onset of an acute rejection, antimyosin scintigraphy and endomyocardial biopsy, respectively, should be performed to confirm and grade the suspected diagnosis.
对18只杂种犬进行了右颈异位心脏移植。研究设计基于三个不同的组(n = 3×6)。所有犬均采用三联药物标准免疫抑制治疗。第二组和第三组在急性排斥反应期间接受高剂量类固醇治疗。在第三组中,将先前受体(第一组和第二组)的天然心脏用作异位移植的供体(“多米诺”原则)。通过每日经壁双心室活检检查心脏,并根据比林厄姆分类法进行分级。细胞免疫监测(n = 345;外周血和冠状窦血的激活指数)和快速傅里叶变换心电图(n = 80;曲线下面积;体表记录)作为每日非侵入性方法。选择性地进行抗肌球蛋白闪烁显像(n = 25;单光子发射计算机断层扫描;心/肺比值),并通过抗体的过氧化物酶染色进行免疫组织学确认(n = 61)。第一组排斥反应的动力学不一致(5.7天后开始),第二组为双相性(明确的无排斥间隔:6.8天)。第三组尽管反复给予高剂量类固醇,但仍出现持续存在的排斥反应,且发病较早(3.2天)。由587次穿刺活检组成的侵入性数据显示,右心室和左心室排斥反应之间无显著差异。51.5%的病例出现明显的局灶性排斥反应,其中54%累及心内膜下。细胞免疫监测在第一组和第二组中与每日活检显著相关(p < 0.001)。冠状窦血的激活指数比外周血高两倍。快速傅里叶变换心电图能非常准确地识别排斥反应的开始(p < 0.01)。抗肌球蛋白闪烁显像的心/肺比值与排斥反应的各个阶段完全对应(p < 0.001)。高剂量类固醇使26%的病例的比值明显降低。过氧化物酶染色显示抗体的典型定位,取决于排斥反应的分级(p < 0.001)。考虑到该移植模型的病理学结果,在临床环境中仅依靠心内膜活检可能不太可取。尽管本研究的结果必须在临床上得到证实,但同时使用细胞免疫监测和快速傅里叶变换心电图可能对术后早期急性排斥反应的日常监测有价值。如果两种方法均提示急性排斥反应的开始,则应分别进行抗肌球蛋白闪烁显像和心内膜活检,以确认并对疑似诊断进行分级。