Grauhan O, Müller J, Knosalla C, Cohnert T, Siniawski H, Volk H D, Fietze E, Kupetz W, Hetzer R
German Heart Institute, Berlin, Germany.
J Heart Lung Transplant. 1996 Feb;15(2):136-43.
Because of the absent lymphocyte infiltrate, humoral-mediated rejection after heart transplantation is not diagnosed by the usual staining technique (hematoxylin-eosin method) of the endomyocardial biopsy specimen. However, humoral rejection is characterized by a distinct myocardial edema caused by capillary leakage. Because tissue edema increases the electric myocardial impedance of the corresponding tissue compartment the electric myocardial impedance method should be able to detect these episodes more reliably than biopsy.
To evaluate this hypothesis eight DLA-matched beagle dogs were subjected to heterotopic neck heart transplantation after multiple sensitization by skin grafts of the heart donor. For electric myocardial impedance registrations rectangular impulses (wide 1 msec) were applied over two intramyocardial electrodes and the impulse response was registered. Day-to-day comparisons were made and an increase of electric myocardial impedance of 10% or more was used as an indicator of rejection. To assess the influence of edema caused by electrode implantation, cortisone administration, narcosis, ischemia, or reperfusion on the electric myocardial impedance, identical electrodes were implanted in the native hearts of five additional dogs via lateral thoracotomy. These animals each received 100 mg methylprednisolone between postoperative days 20 and 22 and underwent heterotopic neck heart transplantation on postoperative day 28 without previous sensitization (protocol 2). Electric myocardial impedance electrodes were also implanted in these allografts (protocol 3). After transplantation myocardial biopsies were done every 2 days and the samples graded according to the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation classification in all dogs.
Despite triple-drug immunosuppression (cyclosporine A, prednisolone, azathioprine) humoral rejection developed in all sensitized dogs as established by immunofluorescent staining of myocardial biopsy samples and functional deterioration. All episodes were diagnosed by electric myocardial impedance (sensitivity 100%), whereas only in one case the biopsy specimen was positive (International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation grade > 1) (sensitivity 12.5%). All eight episodes could be treated successfully, that is, myocardial performance and electric myocardial impedance showed an immediate and full recovery. During the first 12 days none of the nonsensitized dogs exhibited rejection. Protocol 2 indicated that narcosis and the administration of cortisone did not per se have an influence on electric myocardial impedance and the influence of electrode implantation was negligible. Contrarily, edema caused by ischemia and reperfusion during transplantation (protocols 1 and 3) led to a significant increase in electric myocardial impedance. However, after 2 days this edema had faded away such that it no longer disturbed rejection diagnosis.
We conclude that the registration of the electric myocardial impedance diagnoses humoral rejection episodes after heart transplantation not only reliably but also early, that is, before the onset of irreversible graft damage.
由于缺乏淋巴细胞浸润,心脏移植后体液介导的排斥反应无法通过心内膜活检标本的常规染色技术(苏木精 - 伊红法)来诊断。然而,体液排斥反应的特征是由毛细血管渗漏引起的明显心肌水肿。由于组织水肿会增加相应组织区域的心肌电阻抗,因此心肌电阻抗法应该比活检更能可靠地检测到这些情况。
为了评估这一假设,八只DLA匹配的比格犬在接受心脏供体皮肤移植多次致敏后,进行了异位颈部心脏移植。通过两个心肌内电极施加矩形脉冲(宽度1毫秒)进行心肌电阻抗记录,并记录脉冲响应。进行每日比较,将心肌电阻抗增加10%或更多作为排斥反应的指标。为了评估电极植入、皮质类固醇给药、麻醉、缺血或再灌注引起的水肿对心肌电阻抗的影响,通过侧胸壁切开术在另外五只犬的天然心脏中植入相同的电极。这些动物在术后第20至22天各接受100毫克甲基泼尼松龙,并在术后第28天进行异位颈部心脏移植,之前未致敏(方案2)。在这些同种异体移植物中也植入了心肌电阻抗电极(方案3)。移植后,所有犬每2天进行一次心肌活检,并根据国际心肺移植学会的分类对样本进行分级。
尽管采用了三联药物免疫抑制(环孢素A、泼尼松龙、硫唑嘌呤),但通过心肌活检样本的免疫荧光染色和功能恶化证实,所有致敏犬均发生了体液排斥反应。所有病例均通过心肌电阻抗诊断(敏感性100%),而只有一例活检标本呈阳性(国际心肺移植学会分级>1)(敏感性12.5%)。所有八次发作均成功治疗,即心肌功能和心肌电阻抗立即完全恢复。在最初的12天内,未致敏的犬均未出现排斥反应。方案2表明,麻醉和皮质类固醇给药本身对心肌电阻抗没有影响,电极植入的影响可以忽略不计。相反,移植过程中缺血和再灌注引起的水肿(方案1和3)导致心肌电阻抗显著增加。然而,2天后这种水肿消退,不再干扰排斥反应的诊断。
我们得出结论,心肌电阻抗记录不仅能可靠地而且能早期诊断心脏移植后的体液排斥反应发作,即在不可逆转的移植物损伤发生之前。