Lloyd-Williams Mari, MacLeod Rod D M
Department of Primary Care, University of Liverpool, UK.
Med Teach. 2004 Dec;26(8):683-90. doi: 10.1080/01421590400019575.
End of life care or palliative care has been acknowledged as important over the last 30 years and it is essential that doctors have core training in palliative care during their undergraduate training. There is little knowledge of the nature of teaching of palliative care within the undergraduate curriculum. This review was undertaken to determine the evidence to create an effective and appropriate undergraduate curriculum in palliative care. All relevant databases were electronically searched from 1966 until 2001 and selected contemporary work included. Key authors were contacted and grey literature and conference abstracts were searched. Efforts were made to quality grade any evaluation studies of teaching, learning and assessment. Two hundred and eighty abstract citations were obtained--192 papers were excluded due to lack of relevance to this study. Eighty-eight abstracts were obtained and forty-nine papers included in the review. There were no randomized controlled trials of educational interventions or open effect studies. All studies included were descriptive and were graded as level of evidence C. The main findings include lack of consistency in what undergraduates are taught about palliative care. Teaching tends to be fragmented, ad hoc and lacks co-ordination. There are difficulties in recruiting appropriate teachers. Palliative care is rarely formally assessed. Teaching focused more on the acquisition of knowledge and skills rather than attitudes. It is suggested that guidelines should be established within each medical school to develop an integrated curriculum for palliative care with due reference to the multidisciplinary nature of palliative care.
在过去30年里,临终关怀或姑息治疗已被公认为很重要,医生在本科培训期间接受姑息治疗的核心培训至关重要。对于本科课程中姑息治疗教学的性质了解甚少。进行这项综述是为了确定创建一个有效且合适的本科姑息治疗课程的证据。对所有相关数据库从1966年至2001年进行了电子检索,并纳入了选定的当代研究成果。联系了主要作者,并检索了灰色文献和会议摘要。对教学、学习和评估的任何评价研究都尽力进行质量分级。共获得280篇摘要引文,其中192篇论文因与本研究无关而被排除。获得了88篇摘要,49篇论文纳入综述。没有教育干预的随机对照试验或开放效果研究。纳入的所有研究都是描述性的,证据等级为C级。主要研究结果包括:本科生在姑息治疗方面所学内容缺乏一致性。教学往往零散、临时且缺乏协调。招募合适的教师存在困难。姑息治疗很少进行正式评估。教学更多地侧重于知识和技能的获取而非态度。建议各医学院校应制定指导方针,以制定姑息治疗综合课程,同时适当考虑姑息治疗的多学科性质。