Dellinger Theresa A, Youngman Roger R, Laub Curt A, Brewster Carlyle C, Kuhar Thomas P
Department of Entomology, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA.
J Econ Entomol. 2005 Feb;98(1):72-81. doi: 10.1093/jee/98.1.72.
Cultivars of glandular-haired alfalfa, Medicago sativa L., such as '54H69', are currently available and marketed as being resistant to potato leafhopper, Empoasca fabae (Harris). Between 2000 and 2002, studies were conducted to compare the effects of '54H69' and a standard, nonglandular-haired alfalfa cultivar, 'Choice', on alfalfa weevil, Hypera postica (Gyllenhal), and potato leafhopper populations at Campbell and Montgomery counties, Virginia. '54H69' had no effect on alfalfa weevil populations. At each location, densities of alfalfa weevil in '54H69' and 'Choice' were similar, but pest pressure was higher at Campbell Co. than at Montgomery Co. and always exceeded the economic threshold before insecticide was applied. Densities of potato leafhopper also did not differ between '54H69' and 'Choice' in any year at the two locations. Insecticide treatment effectively reduced potato leafhopper densities in the two cultivars, although populations were below the economic threshold at both locations when the insecticides were applied. Overall, postinsecticide treatment comparisons showed that the densities of alfalfa weevil and potato leafhoppers were similar or higher in untreated '54H69' compared with insecticide-treated 'Choice'. In addition, there were no differences in seasonal dry yields between '54H69' and 'Choice' in any year at either location. Our results indicate that the glandular-haired alfalfa '54H69' does not provide acceptable resistance to potato leafhopper and also does not offer a yield advantage to growers in Virginia.
目前已有腺毛型紫花苜蓿品种,如‘54H69’,上市销售时宣称对马铃薯叶蝉(Empoasca fabae (Harris))具有抗性。在2000年至2002年期间,开展了多项研究,比较‘54H69’和标准的非腺毛型紫花苜蓿品种‘Choice’对弗吉尼亚州坎贝尔县和蒙哥马利县苜蓿象甲(Hypera postica (Gyllenhal))以及马铃薯叶蝉种群的影响。‘54H69’对苜蓿象甲种群没有影响。在每个地点,‘54H69’和‘Choice’中苜蓿象甲的密度相似,但坎贝尔县的害虫压力高于蒙哥马利县,且在施用杀虫剂之前总是超过经济阈值。在这两个地点的任何一年,‘54H69’和‘Choice’中马铃薯叶蝉的密度也没有差异。杀虫剂处理有效地降低了两个品种中马铃薯叶蝉的密度,尽管在施用杀虫剂时两个地点的种群数量均低于经济阈值。总体而言,杀虫剂处理后的比较表明,与经过杀虫剂处理的‘Choice’相比,未处理的‘54H69’中苜蓿象甲和马铃薯叶蝉的密度相似或更高。此外,在任何一年的任何一个地点,‘54H69’和‘Choice’的季节性干产量均无差异。我们的结果表明,腺毛型紫花苜蓿‘54H69’对马铃薯叶蝉没有可接受的抗性,对弗吉尼亚州的种植者也没有产量优势。