Zidverc-Trajkovic J, Pavlovic A M, Mijajlovic M, Jovanovic Z, Sternic N, Kostic V S
Department of Cerebrovascular Disorders and Headache, Institute of Neurology, Clinical Centre of Serbia, 11000 Belgrade, Serbia and Montenegro.
Cephalalgia. 2005 Apr;25(4):244-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2982.2004.00838.x.
The utility of the differences between cluster headache (CH) and paroxysmal hemicrania (PH) is limited by the considerable overlap of their clinical characteristics. We compared 54 patients with CH and eight patients with PH in terms of demographic features, characteristics of headache attacks, associated autonomic features, temporal forms of disorders, and response to verapamil. According to our results, clinical features that distinguished CH and PH patients were: maximal pain localization, ocular in CH patients and extra-ocular in PH group; mean attack duration was longer and mean attack frequency was lower in CH patients in comparison with PH patients. Conjuctival injection was the only autonomic sign seen more frequently in CH patients. There were more CH patients with episodic and more PH patients with unremitting form of the disorder in examined groups. Although statistical analysis pointed out a significant difference between these clinical features, there was no clinical characteristic that exclusively belonged to one of these headache entities. Demographic characteristics (age, gender, social background), the other headache attack features (nocturnal attacks, interattack tenderness), the other autonomic signs, as well as the response to verapamil did not differ significantly between two groups.
丛集性头痛(CH)和阵发性半侧头痛(PH)临床特征的显著重叠限制了二者差异的实用性。我们比较了54例丛集性头痛患者和8例阵发性半侧头痛患者的人口统计学特征、头痛发作特点、相关自主神经特征、疾病的时间形式以及对维拉帕米的反应。根据我们的结果,区分丛集性头痛和阵发性半侧头痛患者的临床特征为:疼痛最剧烈部位,丛集性头痛患者为眼部,阵发性半侧头痛组为眼外部位;与阵发性半侧头痛患者相比,丛集性头痛患者的平均发作持续时间更长,平均发作频率更低。结膜充血是丛集性头痛患者中唯一更常出现的自主神经体征。在研究组中,发作性丛集性头痛患者更多,持续性阵发性半侧头痛患者更多。虽然统计分析指出这些临床特征之间存在显著差异,但没有任何临床特征仅属于这两种头痛类型之一。两组在人口统计学特征(年龄、性别、社会背景)、其他头痛发作特征(夜间发作、发作间期压痛)、其他自主神经体征以及对维拉帕米的反应方面无显著差异。