Akhtar Shad Salim, Nadrah Hisham Mohammed
King Fahd Specialist Hospital, Prince Faisal Oncology Center, Buraidah, Al-Qassim, Saudi Arabia.
Int J Qual Health Care. 2005 Aug;17(4):301-5. doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzi035. Epub 2005 Mar 23.
To evaluate the quality of operable breast cancer care in a tertiary care institution.
A retrospective analysis of all breast cancer patients seen in our institution between 1995 and 2000. Data were abstracted from the charts of these patients. Indicators were based on an international consensus conference and other publications.
A tertiary care health care institution.
We evaluated the charts and calculated the percentage for which the internationally accepted quality care indicators were followed during the continuum of care. We also reviewed the histopathological reports to evaluate conformation with the accepted indicators.
Charts of 75 patients (four exclusions, three metastatic, and one male), diagnosed to have breast cancer during the study period were reviewed. Only 28 (37%) patients had triple assessment before a definitive surgical procedure. Pre-operative staging including a CT and bone scan was performed in 58 (77.3%). Among the 50 patients who had definite surgical intervention, the majority had mastectomy (44/50, 88%) whereas axillary dissection was performed in 46 (46/50, 92%). Estrogen and progesterone receptor status was reported in only four (4/50, 8%) and the exact tumor size in 24 (24/50, 48%) of the histopathological reports. Adjuvant chemotherapy was used in accordance with the international standards but radiotherapy was under-utilized.
Our study demonstrated that the quality of breast cancer care in this institution was below the accepted international standards. This study may be used to make interventions for improvement of quality in similar institutions all over the kingdom.
评估一家三级医疗机构中可手术乳腺癌的治疗质量。
对1995年至2000年间在本机构就诊的所有乳腺癌患者进行回顾性分析。数据从这些患者的病历中提取。指标基于国际共识会议及其他出版物。
一家三级医疗机构。
我们评估了病历,并计算了在连续治疗过程中遵循国际公认质量护理指标的百分比。我们还审查了组织病理学报告,以评估是否符合公认指标。
回顾了研究期间诊断为乳腺癌的75例患者(4例排除,3例转移,1例男性)的病历。只有28例(37%)患者在进行确定性手术前进行了三联评估。58例(77.3%)患者进行了包括CT和骨扫描在内的术前分期。在50例进行了确定性手术干预的患者中,大多数进行了乳房切除术(44/50,88%),而46例(46/50,92%)进行了腋窝清扫术。组织病理学报告中仅4例(4/50,8%)报告了雌激素和孕激素受体状态,24例(24/50,48%)报告了确切肿瘤大小。辅助化疗按照国际标准使用,但放疗利用不足。
我们的研究表明,该机构的乳腺癌治疗质量低于公认的国际标准。本研究可用于在全国类似机构中进行干预以提高质量。