Gilligan James, Lee Bandy
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104, USA.
J Public Health (Oxf). 2005 Jun;27(2):143-8. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdi011. Epub 2005 Apr 8.
The usual modes of incarceration have not been found to curb violent crimes significantly. A jail-based programme called the Resolve to Stop the Violence Project (RSVP) was created with the hypothesis that exposing men with a history of serious, recent and often multiple violent crimes to a certain specifiable set of social, cultural and psychological conditions would reduce the frequency and severity of their violent behaviour.
Court and criminal records for 1 year following release were reviewed for 101 inmates who had spent 8 weeks or more in the programme and for the same number of those who had spent 8 weeks or more in regular custody.
Inmates who participated in RSVP had lower rearrest rates for violent crimes (-46.3 percent, p < 0.05) and spent less time in custody (-42.6 percent, p < 0.05). The decline in violent re-arrests increased with greater lengths of stay (-53.1 percent, p < 0.05 for 12 weeks or more; -82.6 percent, p < 0.05 for 16 weeks or more).
Multilevel, comprehensive prevention approaches that: emphasize making available to violent individuals the kinds of tools they need in order to develop non-violent skills and reality-based sources of self-esteem; increase their capacity to experience feelings of empathy and remorse; and provide opportunities to take responsibility and amend the injuries they have inflicted on others and on the whole community, may play an important role in reducing the cycle of violent crime.
尚未发现常规监禁模式能显著遏制暴力犯罪。一项名为“决心制止暴力项目”(RSVP)的监狱项目应运而生,其假设是让有严重、近期且往往是多次暴力犯罪史的男性置身于特定的一系列社会、文化和心理环境中,会降低他们暴力行为的频率和严重程度。
对101名在该项目中度过8周或更长时间的囚犯以及相同数量在常规监禁中度过8周或更长时间的囚犯,审查其释放后1年的法庭和犯罪记录。
参与RSVP项目的囚犯暴力犯罪再次被捕率较低(-46.3%,p<0.05),监禁时间较短(-42.6%,p<0.05)。暴力再次被捕率的下降随着停留时间的延长而增加(停留12周或更长时间时为-53.1%,p<0.05;停留16周或更长时间时为-82.6%,p<0.05)。
多层次、全面的预防方法,即强调为暴力个体提供培养非暴力技能和基于现实的自尊来源所需的工具;增强他们体验同理心和悔恨感的能力;并提供机会让他们承担责任,弥补他们对他人和整个社区造成的伤害,可能在减少暴力犯罪循环方面发挥重要作用。