Liu Yu-Jie, Li Zhong-Li, Wang Zhi-Gang, Wang Yan, Zhou Mi, Wang Ai-Yuan, Cai Xun, Tang Jin-Shu, Zhang Wen-Tao, Gao Li
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Chinese People's Liberation Army General Hospital, Beijing 100853, China.
Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2005 Feb 15;43(4):239-42.
To investigate the feasibility of reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) with hamstring tendons knot implant fixation.
Fifty-two cases of ACL and PCL old injury were reconstructed under the arthroscopy with double bundles hamstring tendons knot implant fixated in the bottle-necked femoral tunnel. The tibia side were fixated by tendon weave suture cross tied a knot at the bone bridge of tibia. In this group reconstruction of ACL was in 25, PCL and ACL at the same time reconstruction in 15, PCL in 12. The failure test and displacement evaluation were used to study the biomechanics of reconstruction of ACL by hamstring tendon knot implant fixation (n = 13) in porcine knees. The control group were reconstructed with bone-patellar tendon-bone B-PT-B and interference screw (n = 11). The tibia side tendon weave suture immobility by cross tied a knot at the tibia bone bridge (n = 7) and interference screw in the tibia tunnel (n = 8).
Forty-nine cases were followed up, average 14.6 months. The results of Lanchman test was negative in 46 cases, positive in 3 cases. Preoperative Lysholm score was 56.7, and postoperative was 92.8. According to the knee joint effective evaluate standard, 46 were excellent and 3 good. The maximal pull-out force of hamstring tendons knot implanted fixation had been greater than B-PT-B fixation by interference screw. There were similar displacement in 100 N and 400 N load between hamstring tendons knot implant fixation and B-PT-B (P > 0.05). Peak force test maximal displacement evaluation and failure energy absorption measurement showed that hamstring tendons knot implant fixation was significantly greater than B-PT-B (P < 0.01). The failure test and displacement evaluation of tendon fixation by weave suture knot at the tibia bone bridge cross tie were greater than B-PT-B fixation by interference screw.
The methods of reconstruct of ACL and PCL by hamstring tendons knot implant fixation are feasible. The advantages include: it is biological fixation, not machine fixation; it may benefit for tendons with bone tunnel healing and decrease medical cost. Decreasing or eliminating displacement is helpful to prevent relaxation after reconstruction of ACL and PCL.
探讨采用腘绳肌腱结植入固定重建前交叉韧带(ACL)和后交叉韧带(PCL)的可行性。
52例ACL和PCL陈旧性损伤患者在关节镜下采用双束腘绳肌腱结植入固定于瓶颈状股骨隧道进行重建。胫骨侧采用肌腱编织缝合在胫骨骨桥处交叉打结固定。该组中单纯重建ACL 25例,同时重建PCL和ACL 15例,单纯重建PCL 12例。采用失效测试和位移评估研究腘绳肌腱结植入固定重建猪膝关节ACL的生物力学(n = 13)。对照组采用骨-髌腱-骨(B-PT-B)和干涉螺钉重建(n = 11)。胫骨侧肌腱编织缝合在胫骨骨桥处交叉打结固定(n = 7),在胫骨隧道内采用干涉螺钉固定(n = 8)。
49例获得随访,平均随访14.6个月。Lachman试验结果46例为阴性,3例为阳性。术前Lysholm评分为56.7分,术后为92.8分。根据膝关节疗效评价标准,优46例,良3例。腘绳肌腱结植入固定的最大拔出力大于B-PT-B干涉螺钉固定。在100 N和400 N负荷下,腘绳肌腱结植入固定与B-PT-B的位移相似(P > 0.05)。峰值力测试、最大位移评估和失效能量吸收测量显示,腘绳肌腱结植入固定明显大于B-PT-B(P < 0.01)。胫骨骨桥交叉打结肌腱固定的失效测试和位移评估大于B-PT-B干涉螺钉固定。
采用腘绳肌腱结植入固定重建ACL和PCL的方法可行。优点包括:为生物固定而非机械固定;有利于肌腱与骨隧道愈合,降低医疗成本。减少或消除位移有助于防止ACL和PCL重建后松弛。