Mahoney B A, Smith W A D, Lo D S, Tsoi K, Tonelli M, Clase C M
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2005 Apr 18;2005(2):CD003235. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003235.pub2.
Hyperkalaemia occurs in outpatients and in between 1% and 10% of hospitalised patients. When severe, consequences include arrhythmia and death.
To review randomised evidence informing the emergency (i.e. acute, rather than chronic) management of hyperkalaemia
We searched MEDLINE (1966-2003), EMBASE (1980-2003), The Cochrane Library (issue 4, 2003), and SciSearch using the text words hyperkal* or hyperpotass* (* indicates truncation). We also searched selected journals and abstracts of meetings. The reference lists of recent review articles, textbooks, and relevant papers were reviewed for additional potentially relevant titles.
All selection was performed in duplicate. Articles were considered relevant if they were randomised, quasi-randomised or cross-over randomised studies of pharmacological or other interventions to treat non-neonatal humans with hyperkalaemia, reporting on clinically-important outcomes, or serum potassium levels within the first six hours of administration.
All data extraction was performed in duplicate. We extracted quality information, and details of the patient population, intervention, baseline and follow-up potassium values. We extracted information about arrhythmias, mortality and adverse effects. Where possible, meta-analysis was performed using random effects models.
None of the studies of clinically-relevant hyperkalaemia reported mortality or cardiac arrhythmias. Reports focussed on serum potassium levels. Many studies were small, and not all intervention groups had sufficient data for meta-analysis to be performed. On the basis of small studies, inhaled beta-agonists, nebulised beta-agonists, and intravenous (IV) insulin-and-glucose were all effective, and the combination of nebulised beta agonists with IV insulin-and-glucose was more effective than either alone. Dialysis is effective. Results were equivocal for IV bicarbonate. K-absorbing resin was not effective by four hours, and longer follow up data on this intervention were not available from RCTs.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Nebulised or inhaled salbutamol, or IV insulin-and-glucose are the first-line therapies for the management of emergency hyperkalaemia that are best supported by the evidence. Their combination may be more effective than either alone, and should be considered when hyperkalaemia is severe. When arrhythmias are present, a wealth of anecdotal and animal data suggests that IV calcium is effective in treating arrhythmia. Further studies of the optimal use of combination treatments and of the adverse effects of treatments are needed.
门诊患者及1%至10%的住院患者会发生高钾血症。严重时,后果包括心律失常和死亡。
综述有关高钾血症急诊(即急性而非慢性)处理的随机对照证据。
我们检索了MEDLINE(1966 - 2003年)、EMBASE(1980 - 2003年)、《考克兰图书馆》(2003年第4期),并使用文本词hyperkal或hyperpotass(*表示截断)在SciSearch中进行检索。我们还检索了选定的期刊和会议摘要。查阅了近期综述文章、教科书及相关论文的参考文献列表,以获取其他可能相关的标题。
所有筛选均重复进行。若文章为治疗非新生儿高钾血症的药理学或其他干预措施的随机、半随机或交叉随机研究,且报告了临床重要结局或给药后前6小时内的血清钾水平,则被视为相关。
所有数据提取均重复进行。我们提取了质量信息、患者群体细节、干预措施、基线及随访钾值。我们提取了有关心律失常、死亡率及不良反应的信息。尽可能使用随机效应模型进行荟萃分析。
关于临床相关高钾血症的研究均未报告死亡率或心律失常。报告主要关注血清钾水平。许多研究规模较小,并非所有干预组都有足够数据进行荟萃分析。基于小规模研究,吸入性β受体激动剂、雾化β受体激动剂及静脉注射胰岛素加葡萄糖均有效,雾化β受体激动剂与静脉注射胰岛素加葡萄糖联合使用比单独使用更有效。透析有效。静脉注射碳酸氢盐的结果不明确。钾吸收树脂在4小时内无效,随机对照试验中没有该干预措施更长时间的随访数据。
雾化或吸入沙丁胺醇、静脉注射胰岛素加葡萄糖是急诊高钾血症处理的一线治疗方法,证据支持度最高。联合使用可能比单独使用更有效,高钾血症严重时应考虑联合使用。存在心律失常时,大量轶事和动物数据表明静脉注射钙剂对治疗心律失常有效。需要进一步研究联合治疗的最佳使用方法及治疗的不良反应。