Pfirrmann Christian W A, Notzli Hubert P, Dora Claudio, Hodler Juerg, Zanetti Marco
Department of Radiology, University Hospital Balgrist, Forchstrasse 340, CH-8008 Zurich, Switzerland.
Radiology. 2005 Jun;235(3):969-76. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2353040403. Epub 2005 Apr 28.
To prospectively evaluate magnetic resonance (MR) imaging findings of abductor tendons and muscles in asymptomatic and symptomatic patients after lateral transgluteal total hip arthroplasty (THA).
The institutional review board approved the study, and all patients provided informed consent. Two musculoskeletal radiologists blinded to clinical information analyzed triplanar MR images of the greater trochanter obtained in 25 patients without and 39 patients with trochanteric pain and abductor weakness after THA. Tendon defects, diameter, signal intensity, and ossification; fatty atrophy; and bursal fluid collections were assessed. In 14 symptomatic patients, MR imaging and surgical findings were correlated. Differences in the frequencies of findings between the two groups were tested for significance by using chi2 analysis.
Tendon defects were uncommon in asymptomatic patients and significantly more frequent in symptomatic patients: Two asymptomatic versus 22 symptomatic patients had gluteus minimus defects (P < .001); four asymptomatic versus 24 symptomatic patients, lateral gluteus medius defects (P < .001); and no asymptomatic versus seven symptomatic patients, posterior gluteus medius defects (P = .025). In both patient groups, tendon signal intensity changes were frequent, with the exception of those in the posterior gluteus medius tendon, which demonstrated these changes more frequently in symptomatic patients (in 23 vs five asymptomatic patients, P = .002). Tendon diameter changes were frequent in both groups but significantly (P = .001 to P = .009) more frequent in symptomatic patients (all tendon parts). Fatty atrophy was evident in the anterior two-thirds of the gluteus minimus muscle in both groups, without significant differences. In the posterosuperior third of the gluteus minimus muscle, however, differences in fatty atrophy between the two groups were significant (P = .026). Fatty atrophy of the gluteus medius muscle was present in symptomatic patients only, with significant differences among all muscle parts. Bursal fluid collections were more frequent in symptomatic patients (n = 24) than in asymptomatic patients (n = 8, P = .021). The MR imaging-based diagnosis was confirmed in all 14 patients who underwent revision surgery.
Abductor tendon defects and fatty atrophy of the gluteus medius muscle and the posterior part of the gluteus minimus muscle are uncommon in asymptomatic patients after THA.
前瞻性评估经臀外侧全髋关节置换术(THA)后无症状和有症状患者外展肌腱和肌肉的磁共振(MR)成像表现。
机构审查委员会批准了本研究,所有患者均提供了知情同意书。两位对临床信息不知情的肌肉骨骼放射科医生分析了25例无症状患者和39例THA后出现转子疼痛和外展肌无力患者的大转子三平面MR图像。评估肌腱缺损、直径、信号强度和骨化情况;脂肪萎缩;以及滑囊积液情况。对14例有症状患者的MR成像和手术结果进行了相关性分析。采用卡方分析检验两组间检查结果频率的差异是否具有显著性。
肌腱缺损在无症状患者中不常见,而在有症状患者中明显更常见:2例无症状患者与22例有症状患者存在臀小肌缺损(P <.001);4例无症状患者与24例有症状患者存在臀中肌外侧缺损(P <.001);0例无症状患者与7例有症状患者存在臀中肌后部缺损(P =.025)。在两组患者中,除了臀中肌后部肌腱外,肌腱信号强度改变都很常见,而臀中肌后部肌腱在有症状患者中出现这些改变的频率更高(23例有症状患者与5例无症状患者,P =.002)。两组患者中肌腱直径改变都很常见,但在有症状患者中(所有肌腱部位)明显更常见(P =.001至P =.009)。两组患者臀小肌前三分之二均有明显脂肪萎缩,无显著差异。然而,在臀小肌后上三分之一,两组间脂肪萎缩差异有显著性(P =.026)。臀中肌脂肪萎缩仅出现在有症状患者中,所有肌肉部位之间差异有显著性。有症状患者的滑囊积液(n = 24)比无症状患者(n = 8,P =.021)更常见。在所有14例行翻修手术的患者中,基于MR成像的诊断均得到证实。
THA后无症状患者中外展肌腱缺损以及臀中肌和臀小肌后部的脂肪萎缩并不常见。