Mwangi Tabitha W, Ross Amanda, Snow Robert W, Marsh Kevin
Kenya Medical Research Institute, Centre for Geographic Medicine Research Coast/Wellcome Trust Collaborative Program, Kenya.
J Infect Dis. 2005 Jun 1;191(11):1932-9. doi: 10.1086/430006. Epub 2005 Apr 26.
Clear case definitions of malaria are an essential means of evaluating the effectiveness of present and proposed interventions in malaria. The clinical signs of malaria are nonspecific, and parasitemia accompanied by a fever may not be sufficient to define an episode of clinical malaria in endemic areas. We defined and quantified cases of malaria in people of different age groups from 2 areas with different rates of transmission of malaria.
A total of 1602 people were followed up weekly for 2 years, and all the cases of fever accompanied by parasitemia were identified. Logistic regression methods were used to derive case definitions of malaria.
Two case definitions of malaria were derived: 1 for children 1-14 years old and 1 for infants (<1 year old) and older children and adults (> or =15 years old). We also found a higher number of episodes of clinical malaria per person per year in people from an area of low transmission of malaria, compared with the number of episodes in those from an area of higher transmission (0.84 vs. 0.55 episodes/person/year; incidence rate ratio, 0.66 [95% confidence interval, 0.61-0.72]; P<.001).
Case definitions of malaria are bound to be altered by factors that affect immunity, such as age and transmission. Case definitions may, however, be affected by other immunity-altering factors, such as HIV and vaccination status, and this needs to be borne in mind during vaccine trials.
明确的疟疾病例定义是评估当前及拟实施的疟疾干预措施效果的重要手段。疟疾的临床症状不具有特异性,在疟疾流行地区,伴有发热的寄生虫血症可能不足以界定一次临床疟疾发作。我们对来自两个疟疾传播率不同地区的不同年龄组人群的疟疾病例进行了定义和量化。
对1602人进行了为期2年的每周随访,识别出所有伴有寄生虫血症的发热病例。采用逻辑回归方法得出疟疾的病例定义。
得出了两种疟疾病例定义:一种适用于1 - 14岁儿童,另一种适用于婴儿(<1岁)以及较大儿童和成人(≥15岁)。我们还发现,与疟疾高传播地区的人群相比,疟疾低传播地区的人群每人每年的临床疟疾发作次数更多(0.84次/人/年对0.55次/人/年;发病率比,0.66 [95%置信区间,0.61 - 0.72];P <.001)。
疟疾的病例定义必然会受到年龄和传播等影响免疫力因素的改变。然而,病例定义可能会受到其他改变免疫力的因素影响,如艾滋病毒感染状况和疫苗接种情况,在疫苗试验期间需要牢记这一点。