Mohanraj Rajiv, Brodie Martin J
Division of Cardiovascular and Medical Sciences, Epilepsy Unit, Western Infirmary, Glasgow G11 6NT, Scotland, UK.
Seizure. 2005 Jul;14(5):318-23. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2005.04.002.
A total of 558 patients with a range of localization-related epilepsy syndromes starting treatment in a single centre were followed over a period of up to 20 years. Overall, 343 (62%) patients became seizure free for 12 months or more (responders), 92% of whom (57% of total population) remained in remission until the end of follow-up. Only 27 (5%) responders relapsed and subsequently developed refractory epilepsy. The remaining 215 (38%) patients never became seizure free for any 12-month period. There were no significant differences in outcome between cryptogenic (56% remission) and symptomatic (57% remission) epilepsies. Patients with underlying cortical atrophy (71% remission; p<0.05) or cerebrovascular disease (70% remission; p<0.01) did better, while those with traumatic brain injury (35% remission; p<0.001) did worse than the remainder of the symptomatic group. Remission rates in patients with cortical dysplasias (60%), hippocampal atrophy (50%) and primary brain tumors (52%) appeared no different from those with other symptomatic epilepsies. Overall, 20-40% patients with each epilepsy syndrome reported no further seizures after starting AED treatment including 21% with hippocampal atrophy and 33% with cortical dysplasia. More than 50% of patients developing localization-related epilepsy during adolescence or in adulthood had a good outcome. Prognosis in those with underlying hippocampal atrophy or cortical dysplasia was not always bad.
在一个中心开始治疗的558例患有一系列与定位相关癫痫综合征的患者接受了长达20年的随访。总体而言,343例(62%)患者癫痫发作停止12个月或更长时间(缓解者),其中92%(占总人口的57%)直至随访结束仍处于缓解状态。只有27例(5%)缓解者复发,随后发展为难治性癫痫。其余215例(38%)患者在任何12个月期间都未实现癫痫发作停止。隐源性癫痫(缓解率56%)和症状性癫痫(缓解率57%)的结局无显著差异。伴有潜在皮质萎缩(缓解率71%;p<0.05)或脑血管疾病(缓解率70%;p<0.01)的患者情况较好,而患有创伤性脑损伤的患者(缓解率35%;p<0.001)比症状性组的其余患者情况更差。皮质发育异常(60%)、海马萎缩(50%)和原发性脑肿瘤(52%)患者的缓解率与其他症状性癫痫患者的缓解率似乎没有差异。总体而言,每种癫痫综合征中20% - 40%的患者在开始抗癫痫药物治疗后未再发作,包括21%的海马萎缩患者和33%的皮质发育异常患者。在青春期或成年期发生与定位相关癫痫的患者中,超过50%预后良好。伴有潜在海马萎缩或皮质发育异常患者的预后并非总是很差。