Sheffer Rivka, Segal Danit, Rahamani Sarit, Dalal Ilan, Linhart Yifat, Stein Michal, Shohat Tamar, Somekh Eli
Tel Aviv District, Ministry of Health, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2005 May;24(5):434-7. doi: 10.1097/01.inf.0000160947.89942.30.
The varicella Oka/Merck vaccine has been shown to be very effective in clinical practice; however, several recent studies reported reduced effectiveness. The varicella Oka/GSK vaccine (Varilrix; GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals), which has been subjected to fewer effectiveness studies, was licensed in Israel for voluntary use in 2000. This study was planned to estimate the effectiveness of the varicella Oka/GSK vaccine among children 1-5 years of age.
Recent reports of varicella were retrieved from the Tel Aviv Health District. Two age-matched control subjects who attended the same day-care center and/or resided in the same neighborhood and had not contracted varicella in the past were recruited for each varicella case. The parents of case and control subjects were interviewed regarding the history of varicella vaccination and the severity of illness.
A total of 151 case subjects (mean age, 2.9 +/-1.1 years) and 298 control subjects (mean age, 3.0 +/-1.1 years) were recruited. Vaccination rates for case and control subjects were 6.6% and 38.3%, respectively (P < 0.001). Disease among vaccinated children was significantly milder, as measured by several indices, including parental perception of the illness, presence of fever, time until the lesions dried and days of day care missed. Vaccine effectiveness against varicella of any severity with these figures was 88% (95% confidence interval, 77-94%), and effectiveness against moderate/severe illness was 100%.
Our data demonstrate that the varicella Oka/GSK vaccine used in clinical practice is highly effective in prevention of varicella (especially moderate/severe disease) among children, including those attending day-care centers.
水痘Oka/默克疫苗在临床实践中已被证明非常有效;然而,最近的几项研究报告其有效性有所降低。水痘Oka/葛兰素史克疫苗(Varilrix;葛兰素史克生物制品公司)接受的有效性研究较少,于2000年在以色列获得许可自愿使用。本研究旨在评估水痘Oka/葛兰素史克疫苗在1至5岁儿童中的有效性。
从特拉维夫健康区检索近期水痘报告。为每例水痘病例招募两名年龄匹配的对照受试者,他们来自同一天托中心和/或居住在同一社区,且过去未患过水痘。对病例组和对照组受试者的父母就水痘疫苗接种史和疾病严重程度进行访谈。
共招募了151例病例受试者(平均年龄2.9±1.1岁)和298例对照受试者(平均年龄3.0±1.1岁)。病例组和对照组受试者的疫苗接种率分别为6.6%和38.3%(P<0.001)。通过包括父母对疾病的认知、发热情况、皮疹干燥所需时间以及错过日托天数等多个指标衡量,接种疫苗儿童的疾病明显较轻。根据这些数据,该疫苗对任何严重程度水痘的有效性为88%(95%置信区间,77-94%),对中度/重度疾病的有效性为100%。
我们的数据表明,临床实践中使用的水痘Oka/葛兰素史克疫苗在预防儿童水痘(尤其是中度/重度疾病)方面非常有效,包括那些日托中心的儿童。