Kimiskidis V K, Papagiannopoulos S, Sotirakoglou K, Kazis D A, Dimopoulos G, Kazis A, Mills K R
Department of Neurology III, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, G. Papanikolaou Hospital, 57010 Thessaloniki, Greece.
Neurophysiol Clin. 2004 Dec;34(6):259-66. doi: 10.1016/j.neucli.2004.10.002. Epub 2004 Nov 18.
Threshold (Th) is a neurophysiological parameter frequently used in TMS studies. The present study was designed to investigate the repeatability of the Th measurements by reexamining healthy subjects over various time points. Overall, 82 subjects (median age: 19 years, range: 12-65) entered the study. Following a baseline examination, there were six retest sessions: S0 (n = 8 hemispheres reexamined, mean interval x = 19 min), S1 (n = 34 hemispheres reexamined, mean interval x = 4 days), S2 (n = 32 hemispheres, x = 29 days), S3 (n = 30 hemispheres, x = 106 days), S4 (n = 30 hemispheres, x = 183 days) and S5 (n = 30 hemispheres, x = 1867 days). Stimulation was performed with a figure of eight coil and Th was defined at 1% steps. At baseline, controls had an MT of 41.1 +/- 8. Mean difference of MT from baseline was 0.62 on S0 (95% confidence interval (CI) of the difference: -1.04 to +2.29), 0.13 on S1 (95% CI: -1.2 to +1.5), -0.03 on S2 (95% CI: -1.1 to +1.06), -2.07 on S3 (95% CI: -4.33 to +0.19), 0.15 on S4 (95% CI: -0.98 to +1.28) and 0.87 on S5 (95% CI: -0.49 to +2.23). None of these differences were statistically significant (repeated measures ANOVA, P > 0.05). The upper limit of MT difference that an individual subject might have with a probability of 95% (measurement error) was 8. The repeatability of the method was found to be independent from the age of the subjects, the magnitude of threshold or the test-retest interval. The topography of corticomotor threshold was also investigated. Minimal threshold values were obtained from a restricted area of scalp sites that always included the fixed stimulation point of the current protocol. Therefore, using a fixed stimulation point is an adequate technique for measuring threshold. In conclusion, threshold is a stable parameter on an individual and group basis. These data quantify the repeatability of the method and may prove useful in the interpretation of findings during longitudinal studies.
阈值(Th)是经颅磁刺激(TMS)研究中常用的神经生理学参数。本研究旨在通过在不同时间点对健康受试者进行重新检查,来探究Th测量的可重复性。总体而言,82名受试者(中位年龄:19岁,范围:12 - 65岁)进入了研究。在进行基线检查后,有六次重新测试环节:S0(重新检查了8个半球,平均间隔x = 19分钟),S1(重新检查了34个半球,平均间隔x = 4天),S2(32个半球,x = 29天),S3(30个半球,x = 106天),S4(30个半球,x = 183天)和S5(30个半球,x = 1867天)。使用八字形线圈进行刺激,Th以1%的步长定义。在基线时,对照组的运动阈值(MT)为41.1±8。与基线相比,S0时MT的平均差异为0.62(差异的95%置信区间(CI):-1.04至 +2.29),S1时为0.13(95%CI:-1.2至 +1.5),S2时为 -0.03(95%CI:-1.1至 +1.06),S3时为 -2.07(95%CI:-4.33至 +0.19),S4时为0.15(95%CI:-0.98至 +1.28),S5时为0.87(95%CI:-0.49至 +2.23)。这些差异均无统计学意义(重复测量方差分析,P > 0.05)。个体受试者在95%概率下可能出现的MT差异上限(测量误差)为8。发现该方法的可重复性与受试者年龄、阈值大小或重测间隔无关。还研究了皮质运动阈值的地形图。从头皮部位的一个受限区域获得了最小阈值,该区域始终包括当前方案的固定刺激点。因此,使用固定刺激点是测量阈值合适的技术。总之,阈值在个体和群体基础上都是一个稳定的参数。这些数据量化了该方法可重复性,可能在纵向研究结果解释中证明有用。