Saint-Aubin Jean, Klein Raymond M, Landry Tina
School of Psychology, Université de Moncton, Moncton, New Brunswick, Canada E1A 3E9.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2005 Jun;91(2):158-82. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2005.01.007. Epub 2005 Mar 21.
When participants search for a target letter while reading, they make more omissions if the target letter is embedded in frequent function words than in less frequent content words. Reflecting developmental changes in component language and literacy skills, the size of this effect increases with age. With adults, the missing-letter effect is due to both word function and word frequency. With children, it is unclear whether the growing size of the missing-letter effect across development is due to a larger effect of word function, word frequency, or both because previous studies with children seeking to isolate the influence of word frequency and word function suffer from important methodological limitations. With these methodological limitations eliminated (Experiments 1 and 2), performance in a letter detection task was assessed for children in Grades 1, 2, 3, 4, and 7 as well as for undergraduate students. The results revealed that the influence of word function increases with age, whereas the effect of frequency is fairly stable across ages. Furthermore, normative predictability data collected in Experiment 3 revealed that third graders and undergraduate students were equally good at predicting function slots in a sentence.
当参与者在阅读时搜索目标字母时,如果目标字母嵌入在高频功能词中,他们比嵌入在低频实词中更容易遗漏。这种效应的大小随着年龄增长而增加,反映了语言成分和读写技能的发展变化。对于成年人来说,缺失字母效应是由单词功能和单词频率共同导致的。对于儿童而言,在整个发展过程中缺失字母效应不断增大,这是由于单词功能的影响更大、单词频率的影响更大,还是两者兼而有之,目前尚不清楚,因为之前试图分离单词频率和单词功能影响的儿童研究存在重要的方法学局限性。消除这些方法学局限性后(实验1和实验2),对一年级、二年级、三年级、四年级和七年级的儿童以及大学生进行了字母检测任务的表现评估。结果显示,单词功能的影响随着年龄增长而增加,而频率的影响在各年龄段相当稳定。此外,实验3收集的规范可预测性数据表明,三年级学生和大学生在预测句子中的功能插槽方面表现相当。