Bitterman Noemi, Shalev Ilana
Samuel Neaman Institute for Advanced Studies in Science and Technology, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Isr Med Assoc J. 2005 May;7(5):292-7.
In light of changes in the medical profession, the different requirements placed on physicians and the evolving needs of the healthcare system, the need arose to examine the medical education curriculum in Israel. This survey, conducted by the Samuel Neaman Institute for Science and Technology, summarizes 20 years of medical education in Israel's four medical schools, as the first stage in mapping the existing state of medical education in Israel and providing a basis for decision-making on future medical education programs.
To characterize the academic background of graduates, evaluate their attitudes towards current and alternative medical education programs, and examine subgroups among graduates according to gender, medical school, high school education, etc.
The survey included graduates from all four Israeli medical schools who graduated between the years 1981 and 2000 in a sample of 1:3. A questionnaire and stamped return envelope were sent to every third graduate; the questionnaire included open and quantitative questions graded on a scale of 1 to 5. The data were processed for the entire graduate population and further analyzed according to subgroups such as medical schools, gender, high school education, etc.
The response rate was 41.3%. The survey provided a demographic profile of graduates over a 20 year period, their previous educational and academic background, additional academic degrees achieved, satisfaction, and suggestions for future medical education programs.
The profile of the medical graduates in Israel is mostly homogenous in terms of demographics, with small differences among the four medical schools. In line with recommendations of the graduates, and as an expression of the changing requirements in the healthcare system and the medical profession, the medical schools should consider alternative medical education programs such as a bachelor's degree in life sciences followed by MD studies, or education programs that combine medicine with disciplines such as law, engineering, computer science, among others.
鉴于医学专业的变化、对医生的不同要求以及医疗保健系统不断变化的需求,有必要对以色列的医学教育课程进行审视。由塞缪尔·内曼科学技术研究所开展的这项调查,总结了以色列四所医学院20年的医学教育情况,作为描绘以色列医学教育现状的第一阶段,并为未来医学教育项目的决策提供依据。
描述毕业生的学术背景,评估他们对当前及替代医学教育项目的态度,并根据性别、医学院、高中教育等因素对毕业生亚组进行研究。
该调查涵盖了以色列四所医学院1981年至2000年间毕业的毕业生,抽样比例为1:3。向每第三位毕业生发送一份问卷和一个贴好邮票的回邮信封;问卷包括开放式和定量问题,评分范围为1至5分。对全体毕业生的数据进行处理,并根据医学院、性别、高中教育等亚组进一步分析。
回复率为41.3%。该调查提供了20年间毕业生的人口统计学概况、他们以前的教育和学术背景、获得的额外学术学位、满意度以及对未来医学教育项目的建议。
以色列医学毕业生的概况在人口统计学方面大多较为同质化,四所医学院之间差异较小。根据毕业生的建议,并作为医疗保健系统和医学专业不断变化的要求的体现,医学院应考虑替代医学教育项目,如生命科学学士学位后再进行医学博士学习,或医学与法律、工程、计算机科学等学科相结合的教育项目。