Galambos Colleen, Rocha Cynthia, McCarter Andrea K, Chansuthus Daryl
University of Missouri-Columbia, School of Social Work, 65211-4470, USA.
J Health Soc Policy. 2004;20(1):1-22. doi: 10.1300/j045v20n01_01.
A review of the literature revealed mixed reviews on the impact of managed care on mental health service delivery. Research supports that managed care contributes to a reduction in inpatient costs and an increase in outpatient service use. Other studies suggest that there are problems with access and quality of care. An additional issue is whether or not, and to what extent, mental health services are "carved out" from physical health for patients. This study discusses the findings of a qualitative analysis of Medicaid managed care recipients on the barriers and enabling factors to obtaining mental health services in a full carve-out managed care model. Results indicate that reduced access, quality of care problems, and a lack of integration of care exist. Additionally, recipients' interactions with managed care, service providers, and caseworkers affect their mental health care. The results also report on the tactics used by recipients to cope with service problems. Implications for social work practice and research are discussed and recommendations for service delivery and evidence-based education are delineated.
对文献的回顾显示,关于管理式医疗对心理健康服务提供的影响,各方评价不一。研究表明,管理式医疗有助于降低住院费用并增加门诊服务的使用。其他研究则表明,在医疗服务的可及性和质量方面存在问题。另一个问题是,心理健康服务是否以及在多大程度上从身体健康服务中“分离”出来提供给患者。本研究讨论了对医疗补助管理式医疗受助者进行定性分析的结果,该分析针对在完全分离的管理式医疗模式下获得心理健康服务的障碍和促成因素。结果表明,存在可及性降低、医疗质量问题以及缺乏医疗整合的情况。此外,受助者与管理式医疗、服务提供者和个案工作者的互动会影响他们的心理健康护理。研究结果还报告了受助者应对服务问题所采用的策略。文中讨论了对社会工作实践和研究的启示,并阐述了对服务提供和循证教育的建议。