Edmeads John
Sunnybrook and Women's College Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, Canada.
Eur Neurol. 2005;53 Suppl 1:22-8. doi: 10.1159/000085038. Epub 2005 May 3.
The primary endpoint traditionally measured in clinical trials of triptans for acute migraine therapy has been 2-hour pain relief, a decrease in pain intensity from moderate/severe to mild/none. Although harder to achieve, endpoints such as 2-hour pain free and the composite measure sustained pain free are now preferred as they better reflect what patients desire from medication, namely rapid onset of action, and complete and lasting relief of pain. A comprehensive meta-analysis has shown that oral triptans differ in their ability to achieve these endpoints, with almotriptan 12.5 mg, eletriptan 80 mg and rizatriptan 10 mg providing the highest likelihood of success. Although all triptans have simple and consistent pharmacokinetic features, they also have specific differences that may play a part in their differing clinical attributes. Incorporating tolerability to generate a more stringent endpoint, sustained pain free with no adverse events (SNAE), may provide an even better representation of patients' expectations. Comparison of SNAE rates using data from the meta-analysis of oral triptans indicates that almotriptan 12.5 mg has the best balance of high efficacy and good tolerability.
在曲坦类药物用于急性偏头痛治疗的临床试验中,传统上所测量的主要终点是2小时疼痛缓解,即疼痛强度从中度/重度降至轻度/无痛。尽管更难实现,但诸如2小时无痛以及复合指标持续无痛等终点现在更受青睐,因为它们能更好地反映患者对药物的期望,即起效迅速、疼痛得到完全且持久的缓解。一项全面的荟萃分析表明,口服曲坦类药物在实现这些终点的能力上存在差异,12.5毫克阿莫曲坦、80毫克依立曲坦和10毫克利扎曲坦成功的可能性最高。尽管所有曲坦类药物都具有简单且一致的药代动力学特征,但它们也存在一些特定差异,这些差异可能在其不同的临床特性中发挥作用。纳入耐受性以产生更严格的终点,即持续无痛且无不良事件(SNAE),可能能更好地体现患者的期望。利用口服曲坦类药物荟萃分析的数据对SNAE发生率进行比较表明,12.5毫克阿莫曲坦在高疗效和良好耐受性之间具有最佳平衡。