Yousem D M, Atlas S W, Hackney D B
Department of Radiology, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia 19104.
J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1992 May-Jun;16(3):345-51.
The purpose of this study was to compare CT and MR for the detection of cervical disk herniations. Nineteen patients suspected of harboring degenerative disk disease of the cervical spine underwent thin contiguous section CT myelography (CTM) and thin contiguous section three-dimensional Fourier transform (3DFT) gradient echo MR at 67 disk levels. Blinded readings of a high intensity CSF MR technique for the presence or absence of disk herniation were performed by three neuroradiologists. The intraobserver CT-MR concordances ranged from 84 to 89%. Using CTM as the paragon test, MR demonstrated a sensitivity of 79-91% and a specificity of 82-88% for disk herniation. Mean MR-CT concordance (86%) was nearly equivalent to that of CT-CT intraobserver concordance (88%). When consensus readings were considered, the MR-CT concordance (91%) was slightly higher than that of CT-CT intraobserver concordance (88%). We conclude that thin section 3DFT gradient echo MR with high intensity CSF is a reliable method to screen for degenerative disk disease in the cervical spine, since the agreement between MR and CTM is comparable with the intraobserver agreement of CTM.
本研究的目的是比较CT和MR在检测颈椎间盘突出症方面的效果。19例疑似患有颈椎退行性椎间盘疾病的患者在67个椎间盘层面接受了薄层连续CT脊髓造影(CTM)和薄层连续三维傅里叶变换(3DFT)梯度回波MR检查。由三位神经放射科医生对高强度脑脊液MR技术进行盲法读数,以判断是否存在椎间盘突出。观察者内CT与MR的一致性范围为84%至89%。以CTM作为对照试验,MR对椎间盘突出的敏感性为79%至91%,特异性为82%至88%。MR与CT的平均一致性(86%)几乎等同于观察者内CT与CT的一致性(88%)。当考虑一致性读数时,MR与CT的一致性(91%)略高于观察者内CT与CT的一致性(88%)。我们得出结论,采用高强度脑脊液的薄层3DFT梯度回波MR是筛查颈椎退行性椎间盘疾病的可靠方法,因为MR与CTM之间的一致性与CTM观察者内的一致性相当。