Liang You-Xin, Wong Otto, Armstrong Thomas, Ye Xi-Biao, Miao Li-Zhuang, Zhou Yi-Mei, Wu Qiang-En, Qian Hao-Jun, Fu Hua
Fudan University School of Public Health, 138 Yixueyuan Road, Shanghai 200032, PR China.
Chem Biol Interact. 2005 May 30;153-154:55-64. doi: 10.1016/j.cbi.2005.03.009. Epub 2005 Apr 25.
This article presents an overview of occupational benzene exposures in China based on data published in Chinese medical journals. The data were derived from 384 reports of benzene poisoning or industrial hygiene surveys published in Chinese medical journals between 1960 and 2003. The following information was extracted whenever available: industry, occupation, task, date, benzene levels, sampling location, workplace descriptions and, for case reports, medical diagnosis. Each paper provided one or more sets of benzene data, each set representing a sampling location or job title with one to several measurements including, mainly, breathing zone area concentration measurements, and much less frequently personal monitoring. Two criteria based on data quality were applied to select suitable data for analyses. The selected exposure data were analyzed by industry and time period. Nine hundred five sets of benzene measurements from 72 industries were reported in the 384 papers selected for this review, and 621 sets (68.6%) presented average benzene concentrations, which covered 55 industries. The distribution of the reported average benzene exposures was skewed with a median of 51.5 mg/m3. The average benzene concentrations were below 100 mg/m3 for 406 (65%) of the 621 reported average concentrations. The medians of the reported averages in mg/m3 for the five industries with the highest exposures were: 124.8 for leather products, 98.7 for electronic devices, 75.4 for machinery, 50.4 for shoes, and 50.3 for office supplies and sports equipment manufacturing. These data describe the concentrations and changing patterns of occupational benzene exposure by industry and time period in China.
本文基于中国医学期刊发表的数据,概述了中国职业性苯暴露情况。这些数据来源于1960年至2003年间在中国医学期刊上发表的384篇苯中毒报告或工业卫生调查报告。只要有可能,就会提取以下信息:行业、职业、任务、日期、苯浓度、采样地点、工作场所描述,以及病例报告中的医学诊断。每篇论文提供一组或多组苯数据,每组数据代表一个采样地点或职位,包含一至几次测量,主要是呼吸带区域浓度测量,个人监测则较少。基于数据质量应用了两个标准来选择合适的数据进行分析。所选的暴露数据按行业和时间段进行分析。在本次综述所选的384篇论文中,报告了来自72个行业的905组苯测量数据,其中621组(68.6%)给出了平均苯浓度,涵盖55个行业。报告的平均苯暴露分布呈偏态,中位数为51.5毫克/立方米。在报告的621个平均浓度中,有406个(65%)的平均苯浓度低于100毫克/立方米。暴露水平最高的五个行业报告的平均浓度(毫克/立方米)中位数分别为:皮革制品124.8,电子设备98.7,机械75.4,鞋类50.4,办公用品及运动器材制造50.3。这些数据描述了中国各行业职业性苯暴露的浓度及随时间的变化模式。