Littman Alyson J, White Emily
Division of Public Health Sciences, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA 98109-1024, USA.
Ann Epidemiol. 2005 Nov;15(10):771-2. doi: 10.1016/j.annepidem.2005.02.013. Epub 2005 Jun 9.
To evaluate the validity and reliability of self-reported male balding patterns in an epidemiologic study.
Participants were 100 men 50-76 years old who were randomly selected from a cohort study of over 77,000 men and women. To assess hair patterning, men selected from among 3 sets of pictures that best described their hair patterning at age 30, at age 45, and at their current age. The categories were little or no hair loss, frontal baldness, and vertex baldness. The self-reporting was done a second time 3 months later. An interviewer independently assessed each man's current hair patterning using the same classification scheme.
Test-retest reliability (kappa) of self-reported hair patterning was 0.74, 0.71, and 0.81 for age 30, age 45, and current age, respectively. The kappa for the comparison of the subject's report of current hair patterning to the interviewer's assessment was 0.47.
Hair patterning represents a noninvasive biomarker that may be an indicator of increased disease risk. While trained observers may represent the gold standard, our study indicates that men are fairly accurate in self-reporting their balding patterns and are quite reliable in reporting their hair patterning at earlier ages.
在一项流行病学研究中评估自我报告的男性脱发模式的有效性和可靠性。
参与者为100名年龄在50 - 76岁之间的男性,他们是从一项超过77000名男性和女性的队列研究中随机选取的。为了评估脱发模式,男性从3组图片中选择最能描述他们在30岁、45岁和当前年龄时脱发模式的图片。分类包括几乎没有脱发、前额脱发和头顶脱发。3个月后再次进行自我报告。一名访谈者使用相同的分类方案独立评估每个男性当前的脱发模式。
自我报告的脱发模式在30岁、45岁和当前年龄时的重测信度(kappa值)分别为0.74、0.71和0.81。受试者当前脱发模式报告与访谈者评估结果比较的kappa值为0.47。
脱发模式代表一种非侵入性生物标志物,可能是疾病风险增加的一个指标。虽然经过训练的观察者可能是金标准,但我们的研究表明,男性在自我报告脱发模式方面相当准确,并且在报告他们早年的脱发模式时非常可靠。