Corns Chris
School of Law, La Trobe University, Melboume.
J Law Med. 2005 May;12(4):462-77.
Over the last 20 years, governments in Australia and elsewhere have increasingly embraced the notion of community-based treatment of the mentally ill in preference to detention in a mental health facility. At the same time, governments have also embraced the notion of community-based treatment and punishment of criminal offenders in preference to detention in a custodial facility. This article examines the use of Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) within the Victorian mental health regime, and the use of Intensive Correction Orders (ICOs) within the Victorian criminal justice regime. It is argued that a number of striking similarities can be found in the respective legislative schemes and policy considerations.
在过去20年里,澳大利亚及其他地区的政府越来越倾向于采用基于社区的方式来治疗精神疾病患者,而非将其拘留在精神卫生机构。与此同时,政府也倾向于采用基于社区的方式来治疗和惩罚刑事罪犯,而非将其拘留在监禁设施中。本文探讨了维多利亚州精神卫生制度下社区治疗令(CTOs)的使用情况,以及维多利亚州刑事司法制度下强化矫正令(ICOs)的使用情况。有人认为,在各自的立法方案和政策考量中可以发现一些显著的相似之处。