Prince Katinka J A H, Boshuizen Henny P A, van der Vleuten Cees P M, Scherpbier Albert J J A
Skillslab, Faculty of Medicine, Maastricht University, 6200 MD Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Med Educ. 2005 Jul;39(7):704-12. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2929.2005.02207.x.
There are data that suggest that medical students do not feel sufficiently prepared for clinical practice in the clerkships. The transition from pre-clinical to clinical training causes problems.
To seek quantitative verification of qualitative findings from an earlier focus group study on problems medical students encounter when entering the clinical phase of undergraduate training.
At the start of the clinical phase, all Year 4 students at Maastricht Medical School were surveyed on the transition from pre-clinical to clinical training and its effects on workload, knowledge, skills and learning.
The response rate was 67%. Students were uncertain as to how to behave and act, mainly because they did not know what was expected of them. They experienced a drastic increase in workload and a lack of time for studying. They considered themselves to be moderately prepared with regard to knowledge and they regarded their physical examination skills as satisfactory. Students reported having difficulty applying theoretical knowledge in clinical practice and perceived shortcomings in basic science knowledge. In addition, they felt compelled to change their learning strategies.
The results of this study confirm the findings of the focus group study. The students experienced problems related to professional socialisation and workload and deficiencies in knowledge and the organisation of knowledge. A good starting point for improvement may involve exploring students' suggestions of an extensive introduction into the clerkships, a more gradual transition with regard to workload and closer integration of pre-clinical and clinical education.
有数据表明,医学生觉得自己在临床实习阶段准备不足。从临床前培训向临床培训的过渡会引发问题。
对早期焦点小组研究中关于医学生在进入本科培训临床阶段时遇到的问题的定性研究结果进行定量验证。
在临床阶段开始时,对马斯特里赫特医学院所有四年级学生就从临床前培训向临床培训的过渡及其对工作量、知识、技能和学习的影响进行了调查。
回复率为67%。学生们对如何表现和行动感到不确定,主要是因为他们不知道对自己有什么期望。他们经历了工作量的急剧增加,且缺乏学习时间。他们认为自己在知识方面准备程度一般,并且认为自己的体格检查技能令人满意。学生们报告在临床实践中应用理论知识有困难,并且意识到基础科学知识存在不足。此外,他们觉得不得不改变学习策略。
本研究结果证实了焦点小组研究的结果。学生们遇到了与职业社会化和工作量相关的问题,以及知识和知识组织方面的不足。改进的一个良好起点可能包括探讨学生们关于对临床实习进行广泛介绍、在工作量方面进行更渐进的过渡以及将临床前教育和临床教育更紧密结合的建议。