Peny Jean-Michel, Gleizes Olivier, Covilard Jean-Pierre
Smart Pharma Consulting, 1 rue Houdart de Lamotte, 75015 Paris, France.
Vaccine. 2005 Aug 31;23(37):4610-8. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2005.04.044.
Vaccines are a key contributor to public health, especially in developing countries. Despite numerous demonstrations of the cost-effectiveness of immunisation, vaccines spending accounted for only 1.7% of the total pharmaceutical market in 2002, when UNICEF estimated that 34 million children were not reached by routine immunisation, most of them in developing countries. Several international organizations or initiatives, like the Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunisation (GAVI), have defined a long-term goal of universal immunisation in developing countries. There is an urgent need to estimate the financial resources required to meet this goal. The objective of this study was to anticipate the funding needs for childhood immunisation in developing countries over the 2004-2014 period. The study scope includes all the 75 countries eligible for support from GAVI, and covers existing vaccines that are considered as a priority for GAVI (DTP (diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis), hepatitis B, Haemophilus influenzae type b (as a stand alone presentation or in combination with DTP) and yellow fever) as well as future vaccines (meningitis A and C, rotavirus, human papilloma virus (HPV), malaria, Streptococcus pneumoniae and tuberculosis) likely to be available within the 10-year period. We developed a methodology to estimate the number of doses required, based on disease prevalence and incidence, target populations, introduction dates of new vaccines, coverage dynamics and dosing regimen. The introduction price and price evolution of vaccines over time were modelled, taking into account the type of vaccine, the expected return on investment from vaccine manufacturers and the competitive landscape. Non-vaccine costs (capital costs and non-vaccine recurrent costs) were estimated based on the number of people immunised and number of doses dispensed, using available case studies as a reference. According to the optimal scenario that would consider the provision of all vaccines to all relevant developing countries as soon as they are available, funding requirements to cover the associated total costs over the 10-year period were estimated to be about US$ 30 billion. Vaccines-related costs represent the largest share, with estimated costs of US$ 21 billion (among which 18 billion for new vaccines), the remaining needs being split between capital costs and other recurrent costs. Accounting for the main imponderables (such as delay in vaccines launch compared to industry plans) as well as probable phasing of vaccine introduction in countries, the total costs of immunisation would be reduced to US$ 14-17 billion over the same period. Vaccines-related costs represent the largest share (US$ 7.1-9.3 billion, among which 4.3-6.5 billion for new vaccines). This study advocates for the anticipation of the substantial financial resources needed to (a) purchase and introduce these vaccines in the developing countries in order to reduce the time lag between availability in industrialised and developing countries; and (b) stimulate vaccine researchers and manufacturers to continue research and development of much needed vaccines for the developing world.
疫苗对公共卫生至关重要,在发展中国家尤其如此。尽管免疫接种的成本效益已得到多次证明,但2002年疫苗支出仅占药品市场总额的1.7%,当时联合国儿童基金会估计有3400万儿童未接受常规免疫接种,其中大多数在发展中国家。一些国际组织或倡议,如全球疫苗免疫联盟(GAVI),已确定了发展中国家普遍免疫的长期目标。迫切需要估计实现这一目标所需的财政资源。本研究的目的是预测2004 - 2014年期间发展中国家儿童免疫接种的资金需求。研究范围包括所有有资格获得GAVI支持的75个国家,涵盖GAVI视为优先事项的现有疫苗(白喉、破伤风、百日咳三联疫苗(DTP)、乙型肝炎、b型流感嗜血杆菌(单独使用或与DTP联合使用)和黄热病)以及10年内可能上市的未来疫苗(A和C型脑膜炎疫苗、轮状病毒疫苗、人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)疫苗、疟疾疫苗、肺炎链球菌疫苗和结核病疫苗)。我们基于疾病流行率和发病率、目标人群、新疫苗引入日期、覆盖动态和接种方案,制定了一种方法来估计所需的疫苗剂量数。考虑到疫苗类型、疫苗制造商的预期投资回报率和竞争格局,对疫苗的引入价格和随时间的价格变化进行了建模。非疫苗成本(资本成本和非疫苗经常性成本)根据免疫接种人数和分发的剂量数进行估计,以现有案例研究为参考。根据将所有疫苗尽快提供给所有相关发展中国家的最优方案,估计10年期间覆盖相关总成本的资金需求约为300亿美元。与疫苗相关的成本占最大份额,估计成本为210亿美元(其中新疫苗为180亿美元),其余需求在资本成本和其他经常性成本之间分配。考虑到主要的不可预测因素(如疫苗上市时间比行业计划延迟)以及各国可能的疫苗引入阶段,同期免疫接种的总成本将降至140 - 170亿美元。与疫苗相关的成本占最大份额(71 - 93亿美元,其中新疫苗为43 - 65亿美元)。本研究主张预先筹集大量财政资源,用于(a)在发展中国家购买和引入这些疫苗,以缩短工业化国家和发展中国家之间的供应时间差;(b)激励疫苗研究人员和制造商继续为发展中世界研发急需的疫苗。