Cakmak Ozcan, Celik Huseyin, Cankurtaran Mehmet, Ozluoglu Levent Naci
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Baskent University, Ankara, Turkey.
Am J Rhinol. 2005 May-Jun;19(3):262-8.
The goal of this study was to assess how anatomic variations of the nasal cavity affect the accuracy of acoustic rhinometry (AR) measurements.
A cast model of a human nasal cavity was used to investigate the effects of the nasal valve and paranasal sinuses on AR measurements. A luminal impression of a cadaver nasal cavity was made, and a cast model was created from this impression. To simulate the nasal valve, inserts of varying inner diameter were placed in the model nasal passage. To simulate the paranasal sinuses, side branches with varying neck diameters and cavity volumes were attached to the model.
The AR measurements of the anterior nasal passage were reasonably precise when the passage area of the insert was within the normal range. When the passage area of the insert was reduced, AR measurements significantly underestimated the cross-sectional areas beyond the insert. The volume of the paranasal sinus had limited effect on AR measurements when the sinus ostium was small. However, when the ostium size was large, increasing the volume of the sinus led to significant overestimation of AR-derived areas beyond the ostium.
The pathologies that narrow the anterior nasal passage result in the most significant AR error by causing area underestimation beyond the constriction. It also appears that increased paranasal sinus volume causes overestimation of areas posterior to the sinus ostium when the ostium size is large. If these physical effects are not considered, the results obtained during clinical examination with AR may be misinterpreted.
本研究的目的是评估鼻腔的解剖变异如何影响鼻声反射(AR)测量的准确性。
使用人体鼻腔的铸型模型来研究鼻瓣膜和鼻窦对AR测量的影响。制作了一具尸体鼻腔的腔内印模,并根据该印模制作了铸型模型。为了模拟鼻瓣膜,在模型鼻道中放置了不同内径的插入物。为了模拟鼻窦,将具有不同颈部直径和腔体积的侧支连接到模型上。
当插入物的通道面积在正常范围内时,鼻前通道的AR测量相当精确。当插入物的通道面积减小时,AR测量显著低估了插入物以外的横截面积。当窦口较小时,鼻窦体积对AR测量的影响有限。然而,当窦口较大时,增加鼻窦体积会导致对窦口以外AR衍生区域的显著高估。
使鼻前通道变窄的病变通过导致狭窄部位以外的面积低估而导致最显著的AR误差。当窦口较大时,鼻窦体积增加似乎也会导致窦口后方区域的高估。如果不考虑这些物理效应,AR临床检查期间获得的结果可能会被误解。