Cankurtaran Mehmet, Celik Huseyin, Coşkun Mehmet, Hizal Evren, Cakmak Ozcan
Department of Physics, Faculty of Engineering, Hacettepe University, Turkey.
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2007 Dec;116(12):906-16. doi: 10.1177/000348940711601207.
We evaluated the accuracy of acoustic rhinometry (AR) measurements in healthy humans and assessed the ability of AR in quantifying the dimensions of the paranasal sinuses and certain anatomic structures in the nasal cavity.
Twenty nasal passages of 10 healthy adults were examined by AR and computed tomography (CT) before and after decongestion. Actual cross-sectional areas of the nasal cavity and actual locations of the nasal valve, the head of the inferior turbinate, the head of the middle turbinate, the ostia of the frontal and maxillary sinuses, and the choana were determined from CT sections perpendicular to the curved acoustic axis of the nasal passage.
The AR-measured cross-sectional areas in the anterior nasal cavity were in reasonable agreement with the corresponding areas determined from CT, whereas AR consistently overestimated the passage areas at locations posterior to the paranasal sinus ostia. The nasal valve was identified as a pronounced minimum on the AR area-distance curve. However, AR did not discretely identify the head of the inferior turbinate, the head of the middle turbinate, or the choana.
The local minima on the AR area-distance curve beyond the nasal valve are caused by acoustic resonances in the nasal cavity, and do not correspond to any anatomic structure. The AR area overestimation beyond the paranasal sinus ostia is due to the interaction between the nasal cavity and the paranasal sinuses, rather than to sound loss into the sinuses. Acoustic rhinometry provides no quantitative information on ostium size or sinus volume in either non-decongested or decongested nasal cavities.
我们评估了声学鼻测量法(AR)在健康人群中的测量准确性,并评估了AR在量化鼻窦和鼻腔某些解剖结构尺寸方面的能力。
对10名健康成年人的20个鼻腔通道在使用减充血剂前后进行了AR和计算机断层扫描(CT)检查。鼻腔的实际横截面积以及鼻瓣膜、下鼻甲头部、中鼻甲头部、额窦和上颌窦开口以及后鼻孔的实际位置是根据垂直于鼻腔弯曲声轴的CT切片确定的。
鼻腔前部AR测量的横截面积与CT确定的相应面积合理一致,而AR始终高估了鼻窦开口后方位置的通道面积。鼻瓣膜在AR面积-距离曲线上被识别为明显的最小值。然而,AR并未明确识别出下鼻甲头部、中鼻甲头部或后鼻孔。
鼻瓣膜后方AR面积-距离曲线上的局部最小值是由鼻腔中的声共振引起的,并不对应于任何解剖结构。鼻窦开口后方AR面积的高估是由于鼻腔与鼻窦之间的相互作用,而非声音传入鼻窦导致的损失。声学鼻测量法在未使用减充血剂或使用减充血剂的鼻腔中均无法提供有关开口大小或鼻窦容积的定量信息。