Krejza Jaroslaw, Kochanowicz Jan, Mariak Zenon, Lewko Janusz, Melhem Elias R
Department of Radiology, University of Pennsylvania, Science Building, Suite 370, 3600 Market St, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
Radiology. 2005 Aug;236(2):621-9. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2362031662.
To prospectively determine the accuracy of transcranial color-coded duplex ultrasonography (US) used alone and in conjunction with carotid artery US for diagnosis of middle cerebral artery (MCA) spasm, with intraarterial digital subtraction angiography (DSA) used as the reference standard.
The institutional ethics committee approved the study. Each patient, or members of the patient's family, gave informed consent. One hundred twenty consecutive patients (64 women, 56 men; mean age, 45.5 years +/- 13.6 [standard deviation]) were routinely referred for DSA after subarachnoid hemorrhage. Vasospasm was graded as mild (< or =25% reduction in vessel diameter), moderate (>25% to 50% reduction), or severe (>50% reduction). US was performed 2 hours or less before angiography. The ratio of flow velocity in the middle cerebral artery (V(MCA)) to flow velocity in the ipsilateral extracranial internal carotid artery (V(ICA)) was calculated. Diagnostic accuracy was evaluated by calculating the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (Az). The significance of the difference between the two Az values (for US vs DSA) was determined by using the z test with correction for correlated data.
Nine of 120 patients were excluded because of inadequacy of acoustic windows in the squama of temporal bones. Spasm was mild in 17, moderate in 16, and severe in only nine of 222 arteries studied. Arteries with moderate or severe vasospasm were combined in one group. The best-performing parameters were peak systolic velocity and V(MCA)/V(ICA) ratio. Az values for these two parameters in diagnosis of moderate-to-severe vasospasm were 0.93 and 0.95, and in diagnosis of mild vasospasm, 0.90 and 0.91. Accuracy of the V(MCA)/V(ICA) ratio calculated on the basis of end-diastolic velocity for diagnosis of mild MCA narrowing was significantly better than that of end-diastolic MCA velocity alone (Az = 0.88 vs 0.84, P < .05). The stepwise approach with use of the V(MCA)/V(ICA) ratio after flow velocity measurements in the MCA resulted in a decreased number of false-negative findings in both vasospasm subgroups. The thresholds of highest efficiency were at a mean velocity of 94 and 108 cm/sec and a peak systolic V(MCA)/V(ICA) ratio of 3.6 and 3.9 for diagnosis of mild and moderate-to-severe vasospasm, respectively.
Transcranial color-coded duplex US alone or in conjunction with carotid artery US has excellent accuracy for angiographic detection of vasospasm. Use of MCA velocity measurements and V(MCA)/V(ICA) ratio can increase the accuracy of Doppler US.
前瞻性地确定单独使用经颅彩色编码双功超声(US)以及联合颈动脉超声用于诊断大脑中动脉(MCA)痉挛的准确性,以动脉内数字减影血管造影(DSA)作为参考标准。
机构伦理委员会批准了本研究。每位患者或患者家属均签署了知情同意书。120例连续患者(64例女性,56例男性;平均年龄45.5岁±13.6[标准差])在蛛网膜下腔出血后常规接受DSA检查。血管痉挛分为轻度(血管直径减少≤25%)、中度(减少>25%至50%)或重度(减少>50%)。在血管造影前2小时或更短时间内进行超声检查。计算大脑中动脉血流速度(V(MCA))与同侧颅外颈内动脉血流速度(V(ICA))的比值。通过计算受试者操作特征曲线下面积(Az)评估诊断准确性。使用校正相关数据的z检验确定两个Az值(US与DSA)之间差异的显著性。
120例患者中有9例因颞骨鳞部声窗不佳而被排除。在222条研究动脉中,17条为轻度痉挛,16条为中度痉挛,仅9条为重度痉挛。中度或重度血管痉挛的动脉合并为一组。表现最佳的参数是收缩期峰值速度和V(MCA)/V(ICA)比值。这两个参数在诊断中度至重度血管痉挛时的Az值分别为0.93和0.95,在诊断轻度血管痉挛时为0.90和0.91。基于舒张末期速度计算的V(MCA)/V(ICA)比值在诊断轻度MCA狭窄时的准确性显著优于单独的舒张末期MCA速度(Az = 0.88对0.84,P <.05)。在测量MCA血流速度后使用V(MCA)/V(ICA)比值的逐步方法导致两个血管痉挛亚组中的假阴性结果数量减少。诊断轻度和中度至重度血管痉挛的最高效率阈值分别为平均速度94和108 cm/秒以及收缩期峰值V(MCA)/V(ICA)比值3.6和3.9。
单独使用经颅彩色编码双功超声或联合颈动脉超声在血管造影检测血管痉挛方面具有出色的准确性。使用MCA速度测量和V(MCA)/V(ICA)比值可提高多普勒超声的准确性。