Prohorov T, Klein C, Miniovitz A, Dobronevsky E, Rabey J M
Assaf Harofeh Medical Center, Zerifin, Israel.
J Neurol. 2006 Feb;253(2):171-5. doi: 10.1007/s00415-005-0943-4. Epub 2005 Aug 17.
We studied the effect of quetiapine in drug induced psychosis (DIP) in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients with dementia (PDDEM) and without dementia (PDNODEM) in a 6-month open study.
Thirty five consecutive PD patients with DIP (19 of them demented [DSMIV criteria]) were examined. Assessment included Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), UPDRS (motor part), Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (BPRS), Clinical Global Improvement Scale (CGIS) and Hamilton test (for depression). Quetiapine was administered in a flexible dose 25-600 mg daily. Out of the 35 patients included in the study, 24 completed treatment with quetiapine (14 demented and 10 without dementia). Treatment was stopped in 11 patients (5 demented).
Intention to treat patient (ITT) analysis did not show a significant quetiapine effect (BPRS), although in about 30% a good outcome was reported by the family (CGIS). Among the patients who completed the study (n = 24), in the PDNODEM group (n = 10) BPRS improved almost significantly (p = 0.06) while in the PDDEM group the BPRS did not change. According to the CGIS, a good improvement was observed in 50% of the PDDEM group (7/14) and 40% of the PDNODEM group (4/10). Motor features of PD patients worsened mildly (p = 0.05) in the PDDEM group.
In this open trial, quetiapine was not beneficial in the ITT group using the BPRS, although families reported improvement in about 30% of patients (CGIS). Among patients who completed the study, quetiapine was more effective in the PDNODEM group. A double blind study with quetiapine is required.
在一项为期6个月的开放性研究中,我们研究了喹硫平对帕金森病(PD)伴痴呆(PDDEM)和不伴痴呆(PDNODEM)患者药物性精神病(DIP)的影响。
对35例连续的患有DIP的PD患者(其中19例符合痴呆的DSMIV标准)进行了检查。评估包括简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)、统一帕金森病评定量表(运动部分)、简明精神病评定量表(BPRS)、临床总体改善量表(CGIS)和汉密尔顿抑郁测试。喹硫平的给药剂量灵活,每日25 - 600毫克。在纳入研究的35例患者中,24例完成了喹硫平治疗(14例痴呆患者和10例非痴呆患者)。11例患者(5例痴呆患者)停止了治疗。
意向性治疗患者(ITT)分析未显示喹硫平有显著效果(BPRS),尽管约30%的患者家属报告有良好结局(CGIS)。在完成研究的患者(n = 24)中,PDNODEM组(n = 10)的BPRS几乎有显著改善(p = 0.06),而PDDEM组的BPRS没有变化。根据CGIS,PDDEM组50%(7/14)和PDNODEM组40%(4/10)的患者有良好改善。PDDEM组PD患者的运动特征轻度恶化(p = 0.05)。
在这项开放性试验中,使用BPRS时,喹硫平对ITT组无益,尽管约30%的患者家属报告有改善(CGIS)。在完成研究的患者中,喹硫平在PDNODEM组更有效。需要进行喹硫平的双盲研究。