Rouprêt Morgan, Hupertan Vincent, Chartier-Kastler Emmanuel
Service d'urologie, Groupe hospitalier universitaire Est Pitié-Tenon, Paris.
Presse Med. 2005 Jun 18;34(11):786-90. doi: 10.1016/s0755-4982(05)84042-4.
To analyse the choice of career of a sample of second-cycle French medical students following the implementation of the recent national-ranking exam (NRE).
All the medical students registered in a cycle of conferences to prepare for the NRE filled-in a self-administered, anonymous, questionnaire in Paris and the provinces during the university year 2004. The items concerned the choice of career, according to the NRE discipline selected, and the mobility required for the success of the project.
Six hundred students were included in the study; 398 were women (66%) and 202 were men (34%), with a mean age of 23.2 +/- 6 years (21-29). Two hundred were at the end of their first cycle (33%) and 400 at the end of their third cycle (67%). Two hundred came from the provinces (33%) and 400 from Paris. Regarding the disciplines selected, medical specialisation predominated (36.2%) followed by surgical specialisation (15.5%) and general medicine (11.3%); psychiatry ranked lowest (4.5%). Psychiatry ranked lowest in Paris (4.8%) and gynaecology-obstetrics in the provinces (3.5%). Regarding geographical mobility, 83.3% of Parisians and 16.8% of provincials refused the idea of completing their third cycle anywhere other than in their area of origin.
The NRE permitted the integration of general medicine among all the other clinical specialisations. Surgery retained a place of choice among the disciplines selected by the students. However, many Parisian students will be obliged to take on a residency in a hospital other than their original university hospital.
分析在最近实施全国排名考试(NRE)后,一批法国医学专业二年级学生的职业选择情况。
在2004学年,所有报名参加一系列为准备NRE而举办的会议的医学生,在巴黎和外省填写了一份自行填写的匿名问卷。问卷项目涉及根据所选的NRE学科进行的职业选择,以及项目成功所需的流动性。
600名学生纳入研究;其中398名女性(66%),202名男性(34%),平均年龄23.2±6岁(21 - 29岁)。200名处于第一阶段结束(33%),400名处于第三阶段结束(67%)。200名来自外省(33%),400名来自巴黎。关于所选学科,医学专科占主导(36.2%),其次是外科专科(15.5%)和普通医学(11.3%);精神病学排名最低(4.5%)。精神病学在巴黎排名最低(4.8%),妇产科在外省排名最低(3.5%)。关于地域流动性,83.3%的巴黎学生和16.8%的外省学生拒绝在原籍地以外的任何地方完成第三阶段学业的想法。
NRE使普通医学融入了所有其他临床专科之中。外科在学生所选学科中仍占据首选地位。然而,许多巴黎学生将不得不去原大学医院以外的医院接受住院医师培训。