Bergez C, Meunier-Gilard M, Songy B, Fourquet N, Le Mehaute H, Salaun B, Boschat J
Unité d'Hémodynamique, Hôpital A. Morvan, CHUR, Brest.
Ann Cardiol Angeiol (Paris). 1992 Mar;41(3):113-8.
Among non-invasive methods for the detection of coronary restenosis after successful transluminal coronary angioplasty, the contribution of exercise myocardial Thallium 201 tomoscintigraphy (MTS) was assessed in a prospective study involving 168 patients with a mean age of 56 (range 32-75) who had undergone 174 successful single vessel angioplasties (86 AIV, 35 Cx, 53 RC) with residual stenosis of 50% or less. After an interval of 6 +/- 2 months, patients were reassessed without treatment by a maximum exercise test (ET) combined with Thallium 201 MTS, 24 hours before follow-up coronary arteriography. Restenosis, defined by a greater than 50% loss of the gain achieved by the initial angioplasty, was seen in 53 patients (30.4%). MTS, with the exception of any necrosed area, was read as positive in case of reversible exercise hypofixation with redistribution. Sixty seven tests were positive, 49 corresponding with restenosis. Four were normal despite restenosis. The diagnostic values of the 3 methods of angina, ET and MTS were 0.43, 0.74 and 0.92 respectively for sensitivity, 0.89, 0.85 and 0.85 for specificity, 0.64, 0.68 and 0.73 for positive predictive value and 0.78, 0.88 and 0.96 for negative predictive value. In total, MTS at 6 months had the best sensitivity for the detection of coronary restenosis after single vessel angioplasty and an excellent negative predictive value (96% alone, 100% combined with ET), eliminating the need for coronary arteriography when it is negative.
在成功的经皮腔内冠状动脉成形术后检测冠状动脉再狭窄的非侵入性方法中,在一项前瞻性研究中评估了运动心肌铊201断层闪烁显像(MTS)的作用。该研究纳入了168例平均年龄为56岁(范围32 - 75岁)的患者,他们接受了174次成功的单支血管成形术(86支前降支、35支回旋支、53支右冠状动脉),残余狭窄小于或等于50%。在间隔6±2个月后,在随访冠状动脉造影前24小时,患者在未接受治疗的情况下通过最大运动试验(ET)联合铊201 MTS进行重新评估。再狭窄定义为初始血管成形术所获增益丧失超过50%,53例患者(30.4%)出现再狭窄。MTS在排除任何坏死区域后,若存在可逆性运动性灌注减低伴再分布则判读为阳性。67次检查为阳性,其中49次与再狭窄相关。4例尽管存在再狭窄但检查结果正常。心绞痛、ET和MTS这三种方法的诊断价值分别为:敏感性0.43、0.74和0.92,特异性0.89、0.85和0.85,阳性预测值0.64、0.68和0.73,阴性预测值0.78、0.88和0.96。总体而言,6个月时的MTS对单支血管成形术后冠状动脉再狭窄的检测具有最佳敏感性和出色的阴性预测值(单独使用时为96%,与ET联合使用时为100%),当结果为阴性时无需进行冠状动脉造影。