Sperry Debbie M, Gilbert Brenda O
Department of Psychology, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL, USA.
Child Abuse Negl. 2005 Aug;29(8):889-904. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2004.12.011.
This study compared experiences of children sexually abused by peers to those of children abused by adolescents/adults. Variables examined included perceived negativity of the abuse, self-reported outcomes, overall psychological functioning, and disclosure.
An archival data set containing retrospective reports of childhood sexual experiences was culled for instances of sexual abuse by child peers and adolescents/adults. An equivalent nonabused comparison group was identified. The Self-Report Outcome Checklist (SROC; Gilbert, 1994b), the MMPI-Hugo Short Form (Hugo, 1971) and a disclosure survey were also retrieved from these data.
Compared to abuse by peers, abuse perpetrated by adolescents/adults was more intrusive and intrafamilial. Both groups rated their experiences as equally negative, and reported equally pervasive outcomes. Those abused by adolescents/adults reported significantly higher scores on the Psychopathic Deviate, Psychasthenia, and Schizophrenia scales compared to nonabused controls; similar findings did not emerge for those abused by child peers. Less than a fourth in either abuse group reported disclosing their experience to a parent. Among those who did not disclose, participants abused by child peers anticipated less support from both parents and more anger from their mothers.
The findings suggest that child peer sexual abuse may be associated with adverse outcomes.
本研究比较了遭受同伴性虐待的儿童与遭受青少年/成人性虐待的儿童的经历。所考察的变量包括对虐待的感知负面性、自我报告的结果、整体心理功能以及披露情况。
从一个包含童年性经历回顾报告的档案数据集中筛选出儿童同伴和青少年/成人实施性虐待的案例。确定了一个同等的未受虐待对照组。还从这些数据中检索了自我报告结果清单(SROC;吉尔伯特,1994b)、明尼苏达多相人格调查表-雨果简表(雨果,1971)和一份披露情况调查问卷。
与同伴虐待相比,青少年/成人实施的虐待更具侵扰性且多发生在家庭内部。两组都将他们的经历评为同样负面,并报告了同样普遍的结果。与未受虐待的对照组相比,遭受青少年/成人性虐待的人在精神病态偏差、精神衰弱和精神分裂症量表上的得分显著更高;而遭受儿童同伴虐待的人则没有出现类似结果。在两个虐待组中,不到四分之一的人报告向父母披露了他们的经历。在未披露的人中,遭受儿童同伴虐待的参与者预计从父母双方得到的支持较少,而从母亲那里得到的愤怒较多。
研究结果表明,儿童同伴性虐待可能与不良后果有关。