Vigliotti A P, Wen B C, Hussey D H, Doornbos J F, Staples J J, Jani S K, Turner D A, Anderson B
Dept. of Radiology, University of Iowa College of Medicine, Iowa City.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1992;23(3):501-9. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(92)90004-2.
Forty-three patients were treated with extended field irradiation for periaortic metastasis from carcinoma of the uterine cervix (FIGO stages IB-IV). Twelve patients (28%) remained continuously free of disease to the time of analysis or death from intercurrent disease, 20 (46%) had persistent cancer within the pelvis, 11 (26%) had persistent periaortic disease, and 23 (53%) developed distant metastasis. The actuarial 5-year survival rate was 32%. The results correlated well with the periaortic tumor burden at the time of irradiation. None of 19 patients (0%) with microscopic or small (less than 2 cm) periaortic disease had periaortic failures, compared to 29% (4/14) of those with moderate-sized (2-5 cm) disease and 70% (7/10) of those with massive (greater than 5 cm) periaortic metastasis. Similarly, the 5-year survival rates were 50% (6/12) with microscopic disease, 33% (2/6) with small gross disease, 23% (3/13) with moderate-sized disease, and 0% (0/10) with massive periaortic metastases. Only 10% (1/10) of patients whose tumor extended to the L1-2 level survived 5 years, compared with 31% (9/29) of those whose disease extended no higher than the L3-4 level. The periaortic failure rates correlated to some extent with the dose delivered through extended fields, although the difference was not statistically significant. Only 8% (1/13) of those who had undergone extraperitoneal lymphadenectomies developed small bowel complications, compared with 25% (7/29) of those who had had transperitoneal lymphadenectomies. The incidence of small bowel obstruction was 8% (1/13) following periaortic doses of 4000-4500 cGy, 10% (1/10) after 5000 cGy, and 32% (6/19) after approximately 5500 cGy. From this, we concluded that the subset of patients who would benefit most from extended field irradiation are those in whom the residual disease in the periaortic area measures less than 2 cm in size at the time of treatment, whose disease extends no higher than L3, and whose cancer within the pelvis has a reasonable chance of control with standard radiation therapy techniques.
43例子宫颈癌(国际妇产科联盟分期为IB-IV期)腹主动脉旁转移患者接受了扩大野照射治疗。12例患者(28%)至分析时或死于并发疾病时一直无疾病复发,20例(46%)盆腔内有持续性癌灶,11例(26%)腹主动脉旁有持续性病灶,23例(53%)发生远处转移。精算5年生存率为32%。结果与照射时腹主动脉旁肿瘤负荷密切相关。19例腹主动脉旁有微小或小(小于2 cm)病灶的患者无一例(0%)发生腹主动脉旁失败,相比之下,中等大小(2-5 cm)病灶患者中有29%(4/14)发生失败,腹主动脉旁有大块(大于5 cm)转移灶的患者中有70%(7/10)发生失败。同样,微小病灶患者的5年生存率为50%(6/12),肉眼可见小病灶患者为33%(2/6),中等大小病灶患者为23%(3/13),腹主动脉旁有大块转移灶患者为0%(0/10)。肿瘤扩展至L1-2水平的患者中只有10%(1/10)存活5年,而疾病扩展不高于L3-4水平的患者中有31%(9/29)存活5年。腹主动脉旁失败率在一定程度上与通过扩大野给予的剂量相关,尽管差异无统计学意义。接受腹膜外淋巴结清扫术的患者中只有8%(1/13)发生小肠并发症,而接受经腹淋巴结清扫术的患者中有25%(7/29)发生。腹主动脉旁剂量为4000-4500 cGy后小肠梗阻发生率为8%(1/13),5000 cGy后为10%(1/10),约5500 cGy后为32%(6/19)。由此我们得出结论,最能从扩大野照射中获益的患者亚组是那些治疗时腹主动脉旁残留病灶大小小于2 cm、疾病扩展不高于L3且盆腔内癌症有合理机会通过标准放疗技术得到控制的患者。