Stoddard Anne M, Krieger Nancy, Barbeau Elizabeth M, Bennett Gary G, Fay Martha E, Sorensen Glorian, Emmons Karen
New England Research Institutes, 9 Galen St, Watertown, MA 02472, USA.
Prev Chronic Dis. 2005 Oct;2(4):A10. Epub 2005 Sep 15.
Few papers address the methodological challenges in recruiting participants for studies of cancer prevention interventions designed for multiracial and multiethnic working-class populations. This paper reports the results of the sample selection and survey methods for two group-randomized intervention studies.
The two group-randomized intervention studies, Healthy Directions-Small Business (HD-SB) and Healthy Directions-Health Centers (HD-HC), included a worksite-based study in 26 small manufacturing businesses and a study in 10 outpatient health centers. We used selection and recruitment methods to obtain a multiracial and multiethnic working-class study sample. In 2000 and 2001, we assessed baseline measures of sociodemographic characteristics and behavioral outcomes by self-report. We then computed intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs).
Of the 1740 participants in the HD-SB study, 68% were non-Hispanic whites, and 76% had working-class occupations. In the HD-HC study, 59% of 2219 participants were non-Hispanic whites. Among those who worked, 51% had working-class occupations. Large percentages of both samples reported not meeting recommended guidelines for the target behaviors. For example, 86% of members of both samples consumed fewer than the recommended five servings of fruits and vegetables per day. The ICCs for the four target behaviors in HD-SB were between 0.006 and 0.02. In the HD-HC study, the ICCs ranged from 0.0004 to 0.003.
The two studies were successful in recruiting multiracial and multiethnic working-class participants. Researchers will find the estimates of the primary outcomes and their ICCs useful for planning future studies.
很少有论文探讨为多种族和多民族工人阶级人群设计的癌症预防干预研究在招募参与者时所面临的方法学挑战。本文报告了两项组随机干预研究的样本选择和调查方法的结果。
两项组随机干预研究,即健康方向 - 小企业(HD - SB)和健康方向 - 健康中心(HD - HC),包括一项在26家小型制造企业开展的基于工作场所的研究和一项在10家门诊健康中心开展的研究。我们使用选择和招募方法来获取一个多种族和多民族的工人阶级研究样本。在2000年和2001年,我们通过自我报告评估社会人口学特征和行为结果的基线测量值。然后我们计算组内相关系数(ICC)。
在HD - SB研究的1740名参与者中,68%是非西班牙裔白人,76%从事工人阶级职业。在HD - HC研究中,2219名参与者中有59%是非西班牙裔白人。在有工作的人群中,51%从事工人阶级职业。两个样本中很大比例的人报告未达到目标行为的推荐指南。例如,两个样本中86%的成员每天食用的水果和蔬菜少于推荐的五份。HD - SB中四种目标行为的ICC在0.006至0.02之间。在HD - HC研究中,ICC范围为0.0004至0.003。
这两项研究成功招募了多种族和多民族的工人阶级参与者。研究人员会发现主要结果的估计值及其ICC对规划未来研究有用。