Azam Matloob, Bhatti Nasera, Krishin Jai
Children's Hospital, Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Seizure. 2005 Dec;14(8):552-6. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2005.08.009. Epub 2005 Sep 23.
Adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH) and prednisone are both used to treat infantile spasms (IS) in West syndrome. In many countries, ACTH is expensive and difficult to obtain whereas, prednisone or prednisolone are cheap, given orally and easily available.
The purpose of this retrospective data analysis was to compare the efficacy and cost of ACTH and prednisolone in the treatment of IS from the perspective of a developing country.
Patients admitted with West syndrome in Children's Hospital, Islamabad, between January 1995 and December 2001 were included in the analysis. The diagnosis was made after eliciting a history of characteristic seizures and detecting hypsarrhythmia on the EEG. Parents were offered the use of either ACTH administered by intramuscular injection or prednisolone given orally. ACTH was expensive and difficult to obtain whereas prednisolone was cheap and easily available.
One hundred and five children were included in the study. Sixty-three were boys and their age ranged from 2 months to 3 years with a mean of 11 months. Thirty-three children received ACTH injections; 27 showed improvement and 11 remained spasms free after discontinuation of injections. Seventy-two patients were given oral prednisolone, 51 responded and 17 remained spasms free after oral steroids were stopped. Overall outcome was similar in both groups. The cost of ACTH injection was more than 100 times the cost of oral prednisolone.
No significant difference was seen in the final outcome in both treatment groups. Since prednisolone is inexpensive, easily available and given orally, it is the preferred mode of therapy.
促肾上腺皮质激素(ACTH)和泼尼松均用于治疗韦斯特综合征中的婴儿痉挛症(IS)。在许多国家,ACTH价格昂贵且难以获取,而泼尼松或泼尼松龙价格便宜,口服给药且容易获得。
本回顾性数据分析的目的是从一个发展中国家的角度比较ACTH和泼尼松龙治疗IS的疗效和成本。
纳入1995年1月至2001年12月在伊斯兰堡儿童医院因韦斯特综合征入院的患者进行分析。在询问特征性癫痫发作病史并在脑电图上检测到高峰节律紊乱后做出诊断。向家长提供肌肉注射ACTH或口服泼尼松龙的选择。ACTH价格昂贵且难以获取,而泼尼松龙价格便宜且容易获得。
105名儿童纳入研究。63名是男孩,年龄从2个月到3岁不等,平均为11个月。33名儿童接受了ACTH注射;27名有改善,11名在停止注射后无痉挛发作。72名患者口服泼尼松龙,51名有反应,17名在停用口服类固醇后无痉挛发作。两组总体结果相似。ACTH注射的成本是口服泼尼松龙成本的100倍以上。
两个治疗组的最终结果无显著差异。由于泼尼松龙价格便宜、容易获得且口服给药,它是首选的治疗方式。